Typography as Sonic Blueprint: A Manifesto for the Architectural Language of Text in New Music

Typography as Sonic Blueprint: A Manifesto for the Architectural Language of Text in New Music

Introduction

To think of a score as merely an artifact of sound is a limitation.  It is a resignation to an antiquated system of symbolic constraints. In the compositional frontier of contemporary new music, text and typography no longer serve as subordinate tools to sound but as primary actors in a new architectural language of musical thought. Drawing from the destabilizing visual grammars of David Carson, the tactile materiality of Agostino Bonalumi, the conceptual irreverence of Piero Manzoni, the unsettling constructions of Thomas Demand, and the experimental cinematic manipulations of Jennifer Walsh, this discourse examines how text, neologisms, and typographic constructs architect new interpretative spaces for the performer, creating an interdisciplinary landscape where sound, type, and visuality intersect.

Text is no longer read; it is inhabited. Typography ceases to be merely visual, instead becoming tensile, pulling the performer between interpretative extremes. The compositional regime of text-as-music thrives in this liminality, where the boundaries between sound, architecture, and material collapse into a resonant void.

---

Typography as Structural Instability: The Influence of David Carson

Let's take David Carson’s typographic disobedience.  His disintegration of form into semiotic chaos provides an apt foundation for considering the role of type in contemporary composition. His designs, marked by fractured alignments and unpredictable hierarchies, resist the fixity of meaning. Similarly, text in new music is deployed as a destabilizing architecture, shifting from instruction to suggestion, from sonic blueprint to abstract provocation.

Take a hypothetical typographic score influenced by Carson’s visual language:

• Neologisms such as Vistrallic or Obfuscene are fragmented, scattered across the score in disjointed alignments, forcing the performer to reconstruct their interpretative paths.
• Overlapping layers of type oscillate between legibility and opacity, introducing a temporal instability where reading becomes a dynamic act of discovery.
• Typographic weight and texture (bold, translucent, skewed) suggest timbral qualities, embedding sonic cues directly into visual design.
• 
  
  

Carson’s rejection of conventional typographic order transforms the score into a nonlinear, multidimensional object. For the performer, this is not a roadmap but a labyrinth.  It is a space to be navigated, resisted, and reimagined.

---

The Tactile Horizon: Agostino Bonalumi’s Material Provocations

Agostino Bonalumi’s works where the canvas becomes a sculptural terrain, its surface punctuated by protrusions and tensions, redefine materiality as a carrier of meaning. His concept of "estroflessioni" (shaped canvases) is mirrored in the material interventions of typographic scores, where text is not simply printed but embedded, raised, or distorted into physicality.

In this regime, the score becomes a haptic field:

• Raised lettering forces the performer to trace text through touch, linking the physical gesture to sonic output.
• Embedded materials such as translucent Mylar, stretched wires, or latex membranes disrupt the act of reading, creating resistance that parallels musical tension.
• Textural contrasts (smooth versus abrasive, pliable versus rigid) evoke specific timbral qualities, translating material into sound.

The performer inhabits the score not as a flat page but as an affective architecture, where the physical act of reading becomes a sculptural performance in itself.

---

Conceptual Subversion: Piero Manzoni and the Absurdity of Text

Piero Manzoni’s irreverent conceptual gestures such as his canned Merda d’artista, his plinths declaring individuals as "living works of art" challenge the sanctity of artistic form. In the context of text in music, his ethos translates into an embrace of absurdity and irrelevance as generative forces.

Imagine a typographic score that employs Manzoni’s spirit of subversion:

• Neologisms such as Somaticor or Anaesthovalence mimic pharmaceutical nomenclature (as in my hypothetical pharmacopeia), but their meanings are deliberately left undefined, forcing performers to navigate their ambiguity.
• Typographic gestures where words are printed upside-down, mirrored, or partially obscured provoke interpretative crises, where performers must negotiate between visual absurdity and sonic coherence.
• Blank spaces punctuate the text, functioning as silent "intervals" that demand sonic imagination rather than explicit notation.

Manzoni’s legacy in this domain is a permission slip for the composer to disrupt expectation, to revel in the absurd, and to create scores that are as much conceptual provocations as they are musical instructions.

---

Constructed Realities: Thomas Demand and the Staged Score

Thomas Demand’s photographic works are meticulously fabricated paper models photographed to simulate hyper-real spaces that interrogate the boundaries between authenticity and artifice. This approach parallels the typographic score, where the "reality" of text as a vehicle for meaning is destabilized by its architectural staging.

Demand’s influence manifests in scores that stage text as both construction and illusion:

• Words are fragmented into modular units, which the performer must assemble or disassemble into coherent structures.
• Layers of translucent type create shifting perspectives, where certain words or phrases emerge only under specific angles of light or manipulation.
• The score’s physicality...its folds, layers, and distortions mimic the constructed nature of Demand’s models, inviting the performer to question the authenticity of their interpretative decisions.

In this constructed typographic space, text becomes a site of negotiation, where meaning is as much a product of the performer’s agency as the composer’s intent.

---

Cinematic Manipulations: Jennifer Walsh and Temporal Typography

Jennifer Walsh’s experimental films, where text, sound, and image converge into volatile assemblages, provide a model for integrating time-based typographic elements into the score. Walsh’s work demonstrates how text can function not just as static instruction but as a temporal medium, shifting meaning through motion, layering, and distortion.

In typographic scores inspired by Walsh:

• Text is animated, projected onto the performance space, or printed on rotating surfaces, introducing a temporal dimension where meaning evolves in real-time.
• Filmic techniques that dissolves, cuts, and overlays are translated into typographic gestures, where text layers interact dynamically, creating rhythmic and timbral cues.
• The score operates as a cinematic sequence, where the performer must navigate its temporal logic, synchronizing sound with the text’s visual flux.

Walsh’s approach redefines the score as a time-based medium, where the typographic and the sonic are in constant dialogue.

---

Text as Monumental Alternative: Toward a Typographic Future

The convergence of influences, be it Carson’s typographic disobedience, Bonalumi’s material provocations, Manzoni’s absurdist subversions, Demand’s constructed realities, and Walsh’s cinematic manipulations positions text as a monumental alternative to traditional notation. In this future, text operates not as a secondary medium but as a primary architecture of sound, space, and interpretation.

Key propositions for this typographic future include:

1. Neologisms as Sonic Triggers: Invented words function as nodes of ambiguity, where performers generate meaning through association, phonetics, and context.
2. Material Interventions: The score as a tactile object redefines reading as an embodied act, linking physical gesture to sonic output.
3. Temporal Typography: Animated, layered, or projected text introduces time as a compositional dimension, collapsing the boundaries between score, stage, and screen.

In the typographic score, language becomes architecture, sound becomes space, and performance becomes construction—a resonant interplay that challenges the very nature of musical notation and interpretation.

My Compositional Approach: Visual Aesthetics and Morphological Sound in Notation

Introduction

My compositional approach is grounded in the interplay between visual art aesthetics and sonic morphology. Rather than treating musical scores as mere instructions, I see them as conceptual landscapes.  They become spaces where sound and image converge, interact, and transform. This paper expands on the principles of my approach, drawing analogies with visual art, reimagining traditional notational systems, and positioning the performer as both interpreter and co-creator.

Conceptual Foundations

At the core of my compositional philosophy is a rejection of linearity and uniform interpretation. Traditional Western notation often encodes time and pitch in fixed, hierarchically structured ways. My work challenges this by embracing non-linearity, visual abstraction, textual layering, and an open-ended semiotic framework. This aligns more closely with contemporary visual art than with conventional musicology.

Non-linear Structure: Refracting Time and Narrative

Much like the fractured narratives of postmodern visual culture, my scores unfold through fragmentation, simultaneity, and multiplicity. Rather than progressing from left to right or top to bottom, they may:

• Exist in spatial clusters

• Allow for multiple entry and exit points

• Encourage repetition, recursion, or omission based on performer judgment

This reflects a philosophy of perception: time is not fixed, but experienced differently across moments and individuals. My scores invite the performer to navigate these landscapes as one would navigate a gallery installation...non-sequentially, intuitively, and responsively.

Graphic and Abstract Notation: Image as Instruction

Inspired by the works of visual artists such as Locher and Wolfgang Plöger, I incorporate abstract geometries, drawn textures, gestural markings, and photographic overlays. These symbols do not correspond to fixed pitches or durations but instead evoke sonic gestures, densities, intensities, and spatial qualities.

Examples include:

• Thick black lines indicating intense timbral focus

• Diaphanous shapes suggesting ethereal textures

• Intersecting polygons representing polyphonic intersections

Such notation resists immediate translation, requiring the performer to engage in interpretive acts that are both intuitive and analytical.

Lexical Idioms, Textual Material, and Hypo-Neology

Central to my notational language is the incorporation of textual forms: words, fragments, invented idioms, and constructed vocabularies. These serve not merely as annotations but as compositional elements with ontological weight.

• Lexical idioms function as sonic triggers or affective markers, guiding the performer through states of articulation or gesture (e.g., "fracture-breath," "spill-rest").

• Text appears in multiple typographic registers.  It may be handwritten, digital, and/or stenciled with each encoding different semantic pressures.

• Hypo-neology, or the creation of semi-words or almost-words, opens interpretive space while resisting fixed meaning. These hypo-words are meant to be sounded mentally or verbally, offering ambiguity as an invitation to embodied cognition.

Text operates as score, score as text. The visual and verbal coalesce into a singular notational logic, extending the boundaries of music notation into the realms of poetry, concrete language, and conceptual art.

Dynamic Interaction: Performer as Co-Creator

Just as visual art is not passively consumed but actively interpreted, my scores demand an embodied, responsive interaction. The performer becomes an essential co-creator, using the visual cues and textual idioms as springboards for sonic exploration. This involves:

• Moment-to-moment decision-making

• Internalizing visual rhythm and spatial layout

• Embodying the affective state implied by the graphic and textual form

This process resembles performance art as much as it does traditional music-making. It prioritizes presence, risk, and responsiveness.

Score as Object and Space

The score, in my practice, is both an object of contemplation and a space of potentiality. It is simultaneously artwork, map, and temporal script. This triadic identity enables a rich multivalence, offering layers of meaning and interpretation that unfold over time and through performance.

Rather than encoding music in a deterministic way, the score becomes a prompt for phenomenological experience.  It is a a site where sight, sound, and word merge, where performer and material converse.

Theoretical and Artistic Influences

My approach is deeply informed by cross-disciplinary artists and thinkers:

• Hanne Darboven: for her use of textual and numerical structure as both visual rhythm and time code

• Ed Ruscha: for his deadpan use of words as image, and the semantic instability of typographic display

• Tacita Dean: for her visual poetics, erasure, and site-specific temporalities

• Cornelius Cardew: for his revolutionary graphic notation and openness to performer agency

• Enrico Castellani: for his manipulation of surface and dimensionality in spatial rhythm

• Alberto Burri: for his material ruptures and the affective properties of physical textures

These influences help situate my work within a broader intellectual and aesthetic continuum, one that spans sound, text, image, time, and materiality.

Toward a New Syntax of Listening and Reading

My compositional method seeks not to direct but to suggest; not to prescribe but to provoke. By fusing visual art aesthetics with sonic morphology and lexical experimentation, I aim to create a syntax of listening and reading that is open, dynamic, and profoundly human. In this framework, the score is not a barrier but a bridge between disciplines, between senses, between people.

Experimental Ideation in Graphetics Tablatures: Echo-Word Determiners, Disruptive Notation, and Interdisciplinary Musical Documentation

"Delinquent Spirit of A Drowned City" for Piano
World Premiere, Paris France.  Palais de Tokyo.  Nicolas Horvath Piano.

Experimental Ideation in Graphetics Tablatures: Echo-Word Determiners, Disruptive Notation, and Interdisciplinary Musical Documentation

The evolution of musical notation has long been entangled with questions of symbolic clarity, expressive scope, and the paradoxical tension between prescriptive accuracy and interpretive openness. In the current landscape of post-notational experimentation, composers and practitioners are increasingly drawn toward alternative and experimental compositional methodologies, where the language of instruction, whether visual, symbolic, or numerical, is as critical to the performance outcome as the sound itself. This movement is marked by the fusion of Graphetics, disruptive tablature design, WET scores, and numerically-structured interdisciplinarity, all of which redefine how we document and enact musical events.

"EV 30"  Experimental Ideation in Visio-Graphetic Tablatures (Felicity Conditions/Finite State Markov Process Control and Case Syncretism)

Disruptive Tablature Design and the Collapse of Convention

Traditional Western notation, anchored in the five-line staff and diatonic pitch grid, was never designed to account for the full complexity of timbral nuance, microtonal inflection, and spatialized sound events present in contemporary performance practice. Disruptive tablature design seeks to replace this inherited architecture with alternative semiotic systems that fracture conventional hierarchies:

• Multi-axis pitch grids where the vertical dimension does not simply represent pitch height, but spectral density or timbral granularity.

• Nonlinear spatial registers, in which the notational surface becomes a navigable topology rather than a temporal sequence.

• Elastic metric divisions that collapse and expand in real time, influenced by performer interaction rather than pre-imposed metronomic regularity.

In this framework, tablature is not merely an encoded set of instructions but a performance ecology.  It becomes an  interface that forces the practitioner into new modes of physical engagement with their instrument or voice.

Experimental Ideation in Graphetics Tablatures ('Echo-Word Determiners)

WET Scores and the Fluidity of Instruction

The WET score, a speculative format emerging from the cross-pollination of graphic notation and environmental recording, embraces instability as a compositional resource. WET (Waveform Event Transmission) describes a system where the “score” is a dynamic audio-visual entity, mutable over time and responsive to environmental or performer-induced input.

A WET score may involve:

• Animated glyphs whose form is altered by sensor data, forcing performers to adapt in real time.

• Sonic cartographies, where shifts in the spectrographic landscape act as navigational cues for vocalists and instrumentalists.

• Interactive environmental tablature, where weather data, crowd noise, or even electromagnetic fluctuations influence the rendering of performance instructions.

In such contexts, documentation becomes less about freezing the musical work into a fixed object and more about generating a living, responsive score-environment.

---

Experimental Ideation in Graphetics Tablatures ('Concatenation, Prototype Theory)

Numerics and Interdisciplinary Construction Tools

Numerical systems, whether derived from algorithmic processes, stochastic functions, or mathematical symmetries, offer a powerful scaffolding for compositional organization. In the realm of experimental music documentation, numbers can function as:

• Parametric anchors for pitch clusters, rhythm density, or spatial placement.

• Cross-disciplinary reference points, enabling collaboration with architecture, choreography, or computational arts.

• Self-generating score matrices, in which performers derive instructions from numerical patterns rather than symbolic notation.

By combining numerics with tactile or visual mediums, composers can generate construction tools that are equally applicable in a studio, gallery, or live performance setting.

Graphetics, Symbology, and Echo-Word Determiners

Within this experimental field, Graphetics occupies a crucial position. As an etic discipline, Graphetics examines the physical form of symbols consisting of lines, curves, textures, and spatial arrangements without allegiance to the meaning systems of any one notation. Its compositional potential lies in its ability to create Echo-Word Determiners: symbols whose visual rhythm, density, or texture encodes performance cues in ways that are both abstract and functionally precise.

For example:

• A series of gradient glyphs might indicate the transition from harmonic clarity to noise saturation for a saxophonist.

• Recursive line structures could direct a vocalist to shift between breathy, whispered phonations and resonant, projected tones.

• Symbols with embedded microtextures such as dots, scratches, or shading could function as temporal markers or articulation cues without relying on traditional rhythmic representation.

The symbology here is not ornamental but instructional, creating a form of notation that is both visually autonomous and operationally effective for the vocal and instrumental practitioner.

Toward a New Ecology of Musical Documentation

The convergence of Graphetics, disruptive tablature, WET scores, numerics, and interdisciplinary construction tools points toward a future where music is less an object to be preserved and more a networked event to be enacted. This new ecology of musical documentation prioritizes:

• Performer agency, where the act of interpretation is inseparable from the act of creation.

• Sensory plurality, where visual, tactile, and auditory cues are integrated into a unified performance language.

• Temporal openness, where scores may transform during the act of performance, resisting closure.

In such a practice, the score becomes a living system.  It is part artifact, part environment, part provocation. The composer is not the sole author, but rather the initiator of a process whose full realization only emerges in the embodied intelligence of the performer.

Neologisms with Lexical Rule:  Excerpt from the score "Explorer, Producer, Stoic After Your Passion" for String Quartet.  Bil Smith Composer. 

Score Page Section from "Acta Combinatorial" for Solo Cello: Utilization of Neologism as Performance Cues.

Rethinking the Opera Score...A Work in Progress

Rethinking the Opera Score: Transformational Notation and the Emergence of Libretto-as-System

The score presented here rejects the historical function of the operatic manuscript as a container for linearity, character, and voice. Instead, it becomes a matrix; at once architectural, procedural, and epistemic. The traditional contract between librettist, composer, and performer is ruptured. In its place: an unstable yet fertile topology of notation as action, page as ontology.

This work does not feature arias, recitatives, or ensemble. Rather, what is offered is an accumulation of panels, systems, and graphic provocations that behave less like a musical score and more like a cartographic interface.  It maps cognition, semiotic interference, and muscular behavior into a unified performance artifact. The notion of “libretto” is absorbed into the visual schema itself. There are no characters. There is no sung language. The libretto, if one can still call it that, is dispersed and distributed across blocks, rotations, densities, and conditional architectures that transform the performer into both reader and medium.

Each component, whether it it a graphic vector, typographic glyph, or notational anomaly, functions as a trigger within a curatorial logic. This is not a ‘score’ to be interpreted for sound alone, but a manuscript to be curated in real-time. Footnotes are not marginalia but spatialized into blocks, giving the illusion of detached commentary, when in fact they are fully integrated executable devices. Their presence instructs the performer not with musical phrase but with categorical imperative. These inserts operate like switches of visual event toggles that determine how sonic material is negotiated. Their opacity is deliberate. They simulate the indexical function of critical apparatus while remaining gesturally generative.

The treatment of time is likewise inverted. The score is not temporal in its organization but accumulative. Time is not measured; it is collaged. Its geometry does not yield phrasing but instead creates terrain of which field conditions through which the performer navigates. Each instrumental line becomes a vector of behavior rather than a voice, each gesture a cue for physical transformation. The typical dramaturgical arcs of opera are displaced by mechanical flux and the emergence of form through repetition, fracture, and reconsideration.

This work poses a fundamental question: can opera exist without voice, text, or character? The answer here is a resolute yes—provided we understand opera as a system of intensities, not identities. The score presented is not merely prefigurative, but meta-operatic. It does not represent a work; it generates one. The libretto is latent, embedded within an ecology of signs, freed from the tyranny of verse and narrative. The result is not an opera that has evolved but one that has mutated into a score that is both surface and depth, both architecture and impulse, both instruction and artifact.

In this schema, notation is not a medium of communication but a mechanism of transformation. The opera is no longer staged. It is activated.

 

W.I.P. (Continued). This page of a new score emerges as a commentary on mediated identity, surveillance, and subversion.

 

This page of a new score emerges as a  commentary on mediated identity, surveillance, and subversion. The central facial obscuration paired with the target-like chromatic block recalls notions of anonymization, algorithmic encoding, and digital overexposure. The weapon-graphic at the lower right doubles as a sonic amplifier and a critique of the militarization of sound and language.

“PILLOPOPEL BEBELBO”, a nonsense phrase arching over a circuitry-like device, delivers a performative utterance or a Dadaist trigger. It simultaneously evokes the absurd and the encrypted.  It is a sonic password in a world of linguistic entropy.

There is a latent Futurist and Lettrist inheritance here, filtered through a post-digital lens: the fixation with machinery, communication systems, the disintegration of the human image into pixel and fragment, and the use of notational systems as cryptographic indexes rather than performative guides.

"Barb's Invisible Chimera" For Solo Flute

 

"Barb's Invisible Chimera" For Solo Flute

Bil Smith Composer

2024-2025

10 Images. 32” X 28”; 81.28 X 71.12 cm

Ink, Graphite, Acrylic, Metallic Powder, Gunpowder on Ilford Galerie Prestige Gold Fibre Silk

Edition of 5 with 2 APs

My new work for solo flute, "Barb's Invisible Chimera"  is a boundary-pushing musical composition that defies conventional expectations of both notation and performance, blending elements of visual art and sound in a way that challenges the performer’s interpretative instincts.

Conceptual Framework

The title Barb’s Invisible Chimera hints at a dialogue with the work of conceptual artist Barbara Kruger. Kruger’s signature style filled with bold textual interventions that critique consumerism and societal power structures.  They find an echo in this work, which manipulates musical notation, imagery, and textual constructs to convey a layered critique of perception and interpretation in contemporary music.

My engagement with semiotic structures extends beyond music into branding and pharmaceuticals, drawing inspiration from the language of medical and commercial industries. My lexicon mirrors the syntacticons found in pharmaceutical branding, where invented words, color associations, and typography contribute to an overarching psychological effect. This aesthetic is reminiscent of Damien Hirst’s fascination with the pharmaceutical industry, aligning the notation of Barb’s Invisible Chimera with the conceptual weight of contemporary visual art.

Notational Structure and The Jubal Project

A central feature of Barb's Invisible Chimera is its incorporation of my Jubal Project notation archetype. The Jubal Project is an experimental notation system that departs from traditional staff-based representation, instead using striking circular color combinations, gestural mark-making, and unconventional symbols to communicate sonic intent. This system redefines the relationship between performer and score, transforming interpretation into an active, almost improvisational process.

This composition is a realization of an "idea of a moment in time for the flutist," placing emphasis on the ephemeral nature of sound and performance. By integrating Jubal Project notation, the score becomes an interactive, kinetic object.  It demands engagement beyond mere visual deciphering.

Materiality and Medium

The choice of materials in Barb’s Invisible Chimera contributes significantly to its impact. Ilford Galerie Prestige Gold Fibre Silk paper, known for its rich, tactile surface, serves as a base for the intricate layering of ink, graphite, acrylic, and metallic powder. The addition of gunpowde, a volatile, elemental material, imbues the score with a sense of transience and combustibility, reinforcing the idea of performance as an act of momentary existence. The materiality of the score is thus inseparable from its musical realization, making the process of interpreting and performing the piece inherently linked to its physical presence.

Performance Considerations

Performing Barb’s Invisible Chimera requires the flutist to engage with the score in a non-traditional manner. The absence of standard musical notation means that the performer must develop a unique interpretative strategy based on:

1. Color and Shape Recognition.  The Jubal Project notation system employs color coding and geometric forms to suggest specific timbres, dynamics, and articulation techniques.
2. Gestural Reading.  The physical markings on the score often imply movement and energy rather than discrete pitches, necessitating a gestural approach to sound production.
3. Temporal Fluidity. The composition resists strict metric structuring, favoring an organic, free-flowing temporality that adapts to the performer’s intuition and physical response to the score.
4. Multisensory Engagement.  The interplay between visual art and sound demands an expanded sensory approach, where the flutist’s interpretation is influenced by visual stimuli as much as by traditional musical thought.

Aesthetic and Philosophical Implications

This work is intended to raise critical questions about the nature of composition, authorship, and the role of the performer. By relinquishing rigid control over musical outcomes, Barb’s Invisible Chimera situates the performer as a co-creator, blurring the line between composer and interpreter. This aligns with postmodern artistic discourses that challenge hierarchical structures in artistic production.

Furthermore, the pharmaceutical branding aesthetic embedded in the notation hints at deeper cultural commentaries, specifically, the ways in which language, imagery, and commodification shape human cognition and behavior. My approach suggests a parallel between the performative aspects of pharmaceutical branding and the performative nature of musical interpretation, highlighting the constructed realities inherent in both domains.

Conclusion

Barb’s Invisible Chimera for solo flute stands at the intersection of music, visual art, and conceptual philosophy. My integration of the Jubal Project notation archetype, combined with his unique material choices and cultural references, results in a work that is both provocative and enigmatic. For the flutist, the piece is less about executing predefined notes and more about inhabiting a shifting, momentary space of sonic and visual engagement.

By challenging traditional notions of notation, performance, and musical meaning, Barb’s Invisible Chimera continues my intent of pushing the boundaries of contemporary composition. It is a work that demands deep interpretative commitment, offering an ever-evolving experience that transcends conventional musical paradigms.