Notation Should Frighten You a Little
On the productive terror of the page
Most musicians remember the first score that scared them.
You open the folder and something is wrong. The page is too dark, or too empty. The rhythms are nested so deep you can't see the bottom. There's a symbol you've never seen, and no key to explain it. Your stomach drops a little. Your first thought is: I can't do this.
I want to make a case for that feeling. Not as an accident, and not as a failure of the composer to communicate. As the point.
Notation should frighten you a little. If it doesn't, I'm not sure it's doing its job.
The comfortable page
Standard notation is a marvelous invention, and I mean that. Five lines, a clef, a key, a meter. In a few seconds a trained musician knows where they are, how fast to go, roughly what the piece will feel like. It's one of the great user interfaces in human history.
But a great interface is designed to reassure you. It promises that nothing on the page will surprise you too much. Everything is where you expect it. You can sight-read it, rehearse it twice, and play it on Saturday.
That's wonderful for a lot of music. It's poison for some. Comfort makes us efficient, and efficiency makes us skim. We stop reading the page and start recognising it. The eyes slide over familiar shapes and the hands do what they've always done. The music gets played. Nobody is actually there.
I don't want my performers to recognise my scores. I want them to meet them.
What fear does to attention
Fear is the most honest form of attention we have. When something frightens you, you can't skim it. Your pulse picks up, your eyes slow down, every detail matters. You read the page the way you'd read a contract you were about to sign with your own blood.
Kafka put it better than I can, in a letter he wrote as a young man:
"A book must be the axe for the frozen sea within us."
I think the same is true of a score. It shouldn't slide into the hands like a warm glove. It should crack something. It should put the performer in a state where habit doesn't work any more and they have to think, with their whole body, about every mark.
Rilke, opening his Duino Elegies, called beauty "nothing but the beginning of terror." I've always found that comforting, oddly. It tells me that the shiver I feel in front of a difficult page isn't the opposite of beauty. It's the doorway into it.
The fear I mean, and the fear I don't
I should be careful here, because there's a bad version of this argument, and I've watched composers live inside it.
I don't mean the fear of humiliation. A score that exists to make players look foolish, or to show off how clever the composer is, isn't frightening. It's just unkind. Performers can smell contempt on a page, and they're right to resent it.
The fear I mean is closer to vertigo. It's the feeling at the top of a high diving board. You know you can do it. You also know you might not do it perfectly, and that the attempt will cost you something. You climb anyway, because the view from up there is worth it.
That kind of fear comes from respect, not contempt. When I write something that asks more than seems possible, I'm saying I believe the player can go further than the standard page has ever asked them to. The difficulty is a compliment. It just doesn't always feel like one in the first rehearsal.
How I build it in
Over the years I've found my own ways of putting a little fear onto the page.
Too much. Some of my pages are deliberately overloaded: rhythms nested inside rhythms, beams stacked like girders, more instructions than any one person can follow. The player has to choose what to let go of, and every choice is exposed.
Too little. Other pages are almost empty. A single mark in a field of white can be more terrifying than a thousand notes, because there's nowhere to hide.
The wrong vocabulary. I've written scores that read like toxicology reports, pharmaceutical warnings and credit ratings. When a page talks about dosage, contraindications or default risk, the performer can't fall back on musical habit. The language itself is unfamiliar ground.
Instability. In my moiré scores, the slightest shift in how you read the page changes what appears on it. In my opera pages, the text turns at every corner until you're reading upside down. The ground keeps moving, so you can't stand on it the way you used to.
Someone watching. Red audit marks, silhouettes in the margins, a box with nothing in it. I like a page to feel observed. A performer who feels watched plays as if every sound counts, which it does.
None of these is a trick. Each is a way of switching off autopilot and switching on the person.
A little, not a lot
Notice the title says a little. I don't want anyone paralysed. Too much fear and the hands freeze, the mind shuts down, and nothing good comes out. What I'm after is the edge: just enough fear to wake you up, not so much that you run.
John Cage was once asked about people's resistance to new ideas. He said he didn't understand why anyone was frightened of them, adding: "I'm frightened of the old ones." I've carried that line around for years. The comfortable page is the old idea. It's the one that should worry us, because it lets us play without listening, read without seeing, and perform without being present at all.
So the next time you open a score and your stomach drops, don't close it. Stay with that feeling a moment longer. It's not telling you to stop. It's telling you you've finally found something worth playing.

































