Sunday, November 22, 2026

"Nobody Is Driving" On empty seats, full dashboards and the waiting score



"Nobody Is Driving"   

On empty seats, full dashboards and the waiting score 

By Bil Smith

There is a small fleet parked in my files and none of it has a license.

A lavender chassis carrying six fat capsules lashed down with blue webbing and plastic buckles, a glass observation deck on top with two yellow seats, three antennas ending in little balls like the stems of cocktail olives. An orange-and-navy roadster with a vintage grille, piled to the ceiling with pods, one of them skewered clean through on a steel rod. A pink submarine on pink tires with butterfly wings where the tail fins should be and a boarding ladder striped like a candy cane. A blue inflatable bladder with 04 stenciled on its side, wrapped in red cord, fed by a corrugated red hose. A sage-green delivery truck sitting very still on a white plinth


If you asked me what they are, the honest answer would be that I think they're scores, and that I'm still finding out what kind.

Anyone who has spent time with British architecture of the 1960s will see where they came from. Archigram drew buildings that refused to stay put. Ron Herron's Walking City of 1964 was a set of enormous insect-legged pods that would stroll across the planet to wherever they were needed. Peter Cook's Plug-In City, the same year, was a megastructure that never finished: a frame with living capsules craned in and out as tastes changed. Michael Webb's Cushicle was a whole dwelling you wore on your back and inflated when you got where you were going. Almost none of it was built. All of it was serious, and most of it was funny, and the group never seemed to feel any need to choose.

That last part is the part I took. A score is also a building that isn't built until someone shows up and stands in it. It might as well have wheels.

Start with the capsules, since there are more of them than anything else.




In Plug-In City the capsule was the unit of change. You didn't renovate, you unplugged a room and craned in another. Look at the lavender vehicle and you'll see the same arrangement: yellow, red, mint, violet and navy pods, each a different size, each held to the frame by a strap and a buckle and nothing more permanent than that. Any one of them could come off at a rest stop. The thing stays a vehicle either way.

That is roughly how I want a score's materials to sit: lashed on where you can see them, so the player can see where one module ends and the next begins and can wonder, reasonably, whether the buckle will hold at speed.

It's hard to say the word capsule in new-music company without someone thinking of Ferneyhough's Unity Capsule, the solo flute piece from the mid-seventies whose pages look as if a flock of starlings landed on the staff and then filed paperwork. The title has always struck me as a beautiful contradiction. A capsule is a sealed container. Unity is what you'd hope to find inside. What you actually find inside is a flautist doing about nine incompatible things at once while being asked, very politely, to make them cohere.

I should say this properly, in the dialect, so nobody thinks I've gone soft. Each capsule constitutes a locally autonomous parametric enclosure whose relation to the chassis is neither hierarchical nor contingent but tensile, mediated by the strap as a site of negotiated adherence, such that the global morphology of the vehicle is continuously re-inscribed by the potential detachment of any constituent pod. The buckle is the formal hinge of the work. It is the moment at which structural intention submits itself to the rumour of its own undoing.

In English: it's all held on with luggage straps, and that's the point.

Then the ladders. Every one of these vehicles has too many.

The lavender one has five or six thin yellow ladders, the kind that come on a sprue in a model kit, running from the running boards up to the capsules and from the capsules up to a railed deck. The orange roadster has white wire ladders and two catwalks hanging off its sides like balconies on a cruise ship that has been told it's a pickup truck. A couple of the ladders, if you trace them, don't arrive anywhere. They stop at the side of a pod with no hatch.

It took me an embarrassingly long time to see what these were. A ladder is a ledger line with rungs. Ledger lines are the short strokes we add above or below the staff when a pitch climbs out of the five lines it was given, and anyone who has read a piccolo part or a contrabassoon part knows how quickly they pile up, until you're counting rungs to find out which note you're standing on. The staff is the chassis. Ledger lines are how you climb off it.

Piranesi got there first, of course, with his imaginary prisons full of staircases that go up into fog and never come down, and Ferneyhough got there second with the Carceri d'Invenzione cycle, seven works named after those etchings, written through most of the eighties. I'm happy to come in third, with plastic.

Here's the dialect again, because I promised. The ladder operates as a vector of ascent whose terminus is structurally withheld; its rungs articulate a quantised trajectory through registral space while denying the arrival that quantisation implies. The performer is thereby positioned not at a destination but within an iterated approach, a condition of perpetual mounting, which is to say: practising.

Which, to be fair, is also what a ladder that goes nowhere is for.

Nobody is driving.

The orange-and-teal rover has a clear bubble cockpit, a steering column, a little chrome dashboard and one cream-colored seat, ribbed like a 1970s dentist's chair, with nobody in it. The lavender vehicle has two yellow seats up on its observation deck, also empty. There's a shape in the cab of the green truck that might be a figure or might be a reflection, and I've decided not to find out.

An empty seat in front of a set of controls is the most accurate picture of a score I know. The thing is fully equipped. The gauges are installed and the antennas are up. It's waiting for a body, and it has no opinion yet about whose. When the player climbs in, the vehicle stops being an object and becomes a duty.

The blue inflatable makes that literal in a way I still find a little alarming. It's a bladder, a big soft drum of blue plastic, and printed across its skin, faint as a watermark, are staff lines with notes on them. The notation is the hide of the thing. Underneath a stenciled 04 the staves curve around the belly and disappear. Red cord is netted over the whole body, the wheels are wrapped in red thread like a road map of veins, and a fat red corrugated hose runs from the body down to a cluster of pressure gauges near the ground.

I keep coming back to those gauges. Our word for a bar of music is a measure, and here is a cluster of actual measuring instruments bolted to a score, reading pressure. That's what a dynamic marking is, if you're honest about it: a request for a certain number of pounds per square inch, from lungs or bow arm or stick, delivered through a hose. Michael Webb's Suitaloon was a garment that inflated into a house. This is a score that inflates into a performance, or deflates into a puddle of blue vinyl, depending on who's on the pump.

In the dialect: the inflatable instantiates notation as epidermal condition rather than prescriptive overlay, collapsing the ontological distance between instruction and vessel; its pressurisation indexes the somatic labour of execution as a measurable, indeed metered, quantity, while the numeral 04 refuses to disclose whether it denominates sequence, catalogue, or merely a jersey.

I'm not going to tell you what the 04 means. Some instructions should arrive sealed.

Two of them don't fit the fleet, and they're the two I trust most.

The pink submarine is a submarine on wheels, which is already a category error, and then it goes further. It has a propeller on top, turned sideways like a desk fan. It has two butterfly wings where a sensible boat would have a rudder. Its portholes are rimmed and riveted and there's a periscope and a couple of plumbing elbows sticking out of the conning tower. The boarding ladder, red and white, is unmistakably a candy cane. Every part of it was designed for a different element. Water, air, road, a dentist's waiting room in 1962. It is equipped to go everywhere and therefore goes nowhere with total confidence.

I think a lot of the scores I admire are pink submarines. They carry instructions for three or four media at once, written with complete technical sincerity, and they leave it to the performer to discover which of those instructions the room they're actually standing in can honour. I'd call that the score being honest about how many places music has to travel through on the way to an ear.

The last one is the quietest. A delivery truck, all one color, a pale sage green, with a little orange ladder hooked on the back and a long pleated bellows along its side like an accordion that swallowed a radiator. It sits on a white plinth. It's the only vehicle in the set that has been put up on a pedestal, and the only one that plainly isn't going anywhere.

That's what happens to scores, eventually. They get archived, catalogued, photographed in good light, placed on a plinth in a library or a museum case or a PDF, and they keep every one of their wheels. The ladders still reach. The bellows still look as if they could breathe. Nothing in the object has changed, only its permission to move.

One last burst of the dialect, for the archive: the plinth effects a transposition of the vehicle from the register of potential kinesis into that of curated stasis, whereupon its mechanisms persist as pure signifiers of capacity, a mobility held in suspension, awaiting the reactivating gesture of a reader who may, at any moment, climb the little orange ladder and simply drive it off the pedestal.

I'd like to see that. I'd like to see the security guard's face.

The Bounce, Six Years Later. Revisiting a 2020 post on careers, memes and the slow roll

 


The Bounce, Six Years Later

Revisiting a 2020 post on careers, memes and the slow roll

By Bil Smith

In 2020 I wrote here that a composer's reputation is built the slow way, score by score, performance by performance, over years, and that we had entered a moment of the bounce. A Google Alert fires when someone types your name. A tweet about a performance reaches thousands of people before the hall has emptied. I said the re-gestures, the retweet and the reblog, had come to carry more weight than the work being pointed at, and I ended by saying that composers still preferred the slow roll of music history to the bouncy meme, but that this too would soon be changing.

It changed. I got the direction wrong, though.

Everything in that post assumed a person on the other end of the bounce. Someone who saw my score, didn't read it, and passed it on anyway because the name and the look of the thing were worth passing on. I was annoyed by that person. Six years later I find I miss them.

Start with the platform I named. Twitter has been X since 2023, and new-music people have scattered to Bluesky, Threads, Mastodon, Instagram, a few Discord servers, and in some cases nowhere. There is no longer one room where a score can ricochet. There are a dozen half-empty rooms with the lights on.

The bigger change is who decides what travels. In 2020 a retweet was still a choice a person made, however lazily. Now the reach of a post is set mostly by a recommendation feed, TikTok's For You page and everything built to imitate it, which shows a thing to people who never chose to follow you because a model predicted they would linger on it. Followers matter less. Lingering matters more. A page of dense notation does well in that system when it makes someone pause their thumb for a second and a half, which is about the opposite of what the page asks of a player.

So the re-gesture I complained about has been automated. The pointing still happens, at a scale Boing Boing never managed, but there's often no one doing it. I used to resent the people who shared a score without reading it. At least they had seen it go by.

In the 2020 post I wrote that the citation, the act of moving information, had more cachet than the object it referred to. I still think so. What I didn't picture was a citation with no one behind it at all.

Type a composer's name into a search box now and the first thing you're likely to get is a machine-written paragraph above the links. Ask a chatbot about a score and it will tell you, calmly and in complete sentences, what the score is about and who it resembles. Some of that will be right. Some of it will be stitched together from program notes, a review, and a stranger's guess. The tone is identical either way, and very few people click through to check.

For a composer this means your work is now being described far more often than it is being read, and the description arrives already finished. In 2020 the bounce at least sent people toward the thing, even if they didn't look closely when they got there. A summary is built to be the place where they stop, and it takes the score's place.

I don't think a composer can opt out of this. You can try to make sure the material the machines read is accurate and your own, which is one reason I keep writing here at length instead of posting captions. I'd rather be summarized from something I actually said.

Then there's the object itself, the thing the bounce was supposed to be about.

People now write prompts for image generators asking for pages of viola notation dense enough to pass for late Ferneyhough, and the generators are very good at it. In seconds you get a sheet with beams, tuplets, microtonal arrows, stacked dynamics, all of it lit like a museum photograph. None of it can be played. The beams connect nothing in particular. The tuplets don't add up. It is a picture of difficulty, and as a picture it is often more striking than a real score, because it was optimized to be looked at.

That's the part that unsettles me. In 2020 the bounce traded on the look of a demanding score, and the demanding score still existed underneath, waiting for anyone patient enough to read it. Now the look can be produced on its own, with nothing underneath, and it will travel just as well. Probably better. The same is true of sound. Services like Suno will hand you a finished track from a sentence of description, and a feed can't tell the difference between that and something someone spent two years on. Neither can most listeners, scrolling.

Sneering at these tools gets nobody anywhere. They do make plain what the bounce was rewarding all along, which was the surface of the work, and the surface can now be made for free.

What can't be made for free is anything that only reveals itself to someone who stays with it.

One of my recent scores has three sums running up its right margin. Each one is wrong, and the way they are wrong matters to the piece. A summary will tell you there's a ledger in the margin. An image generator could produce a page with a ledger on it by lunchtime. Neither will tell you that 16 + 17 + 18 + 29 + 29 − 219 + 24 + 20 does not come to 90, because finding that out takes a pencil and a couple of minutes, and nobody downstream of the feed is spending those minutes. The only way to know is to do it yourself.

I've come to think that's the most useful thing a score can do right now: hold something back from the scroll. Put the meaning where it has to be worked out, by a player in a practice room or a reader with a pencil, and the bounce can carry the picture as far as it likes. The same goes for a performance. A feed can show you thirty seconds of one, but the forty minutes in the room with the player bending a pitch toward 23/16 and missing slightly and trying again doesn't compress.

In 2020 I said I couldn't name a composer who would choose the bouncy meme over the slow roll of history. I still can't. What I didn't see coming was how little the choice would be ours. The bounce goes on without us, faster each year, described by machines and illustrated by machines, and the slow roll is still there underneath it, for whoever is patient enough to dig it out. I can't tell yet whether that's a smaller audience or just a quieter one.

The Banjo Problem: Estrangement Through Unconventional Instrumentation

 


The Banjo Problem: Estrangement Through Unconventional Instrumentation

When the banjo enters a chamber ensemble alongside flute and cello, something breaks. Not the instruments themselves, but the acoustic and cultural contract we've spent centuries refining. The listener's ear, trained to navigate the familiar terrains of string quartet or woodwind quintet, suddenly encounters an obstacle it cannot process using established perceptual templates.

This is not malfunction. This is strategy.

The banjo, with its bright, percussive attack and unwavering associations with folk traditions, bluegrass, and Americana, refuses integration into the Western art music soundworld. It arrives trailing its cultural baggage like tin cans tied to a wedding car: impossible to ignore, deliberately disruptive, fundamentally estranging.

This estrangement is what I call "the banjo problem," though the banjo itself is not the problem. The problem is us. Our listening habits, our genre expectations, our neat categorical boxes. The banjo simply refuses to stay in its assigned container, and in doing so, reveals the artificial nature of all such containers.

The Acoustic Disruption

Begin with the purely sonic. The banjo's timbre occupies a unique position in the spectrum of plucked strings. Unlike the guitar's warm, sustained resonance or the harp's ethereal shimmer, the banjo produces a bright, nasal attack followed by rapid decay. The metal head, stretched over a resonating chamber, creates harmonics that emphasize the percussive strike over the melodic sustain.

In a trio with flute and cello, this creates immediate hierarchical disruption. The cello, with its rich fundamental and complex overtone series, typically anchors chamber music with gravitational authority. The flute floats above, providing lyrical line and coloristic commentary. These roles have been established over centuries of repertoire.

The banjo recognizes none of this.

Its attack is sharper than the cello's articulation, cutting through texture with knife-like precision. Yet it cannot sustain like the flute, cannot sing a legato line with the same breath-supported continuity. It exists in the gap between percussion and melody, refusing to be either entirely.

This sonic ambiguity forces composers and performers to rethink fundamental assumptions about blend, balance, and textural hierarchy. The banjo won't blend. It won't recede politely into accompanimental roles. It insists on its own presence, its own sonic signature, its own refusal to be absorbed.

The Cultural Freight

But acoustic properties tell only half the story. The banjo arrives in the concert hall carrying the weight of its cultural associations, and these associations actively resist art music contexts.

For American listeners especially, the banjo is inseparable from folk music, bluegrass, minstrelsy, Appalachian culture, and the complex, often troubling history of American popular entertainment. These associations are not neutral. They carry class implications, regional identities, racial histories that cannot be easily bracketed or ignored.

When a composer places a banjo in a contemporary chamber work, they are not simply choosing a timbre. They are invoking an entire cultural field, one that exists in complicated relationship to the institutional spaces of concert music. The banjo makes the concert hall aware of itself as a space with boundaries, with exclusions, with aesthetic politics that determine what belongs and what remains outside.

This is precisely why the banjo functions as an agent of estrangement. It makes visible the usually invisible framework of genre and cultural legitimacy that structures our listening. It asks: why is the cello serious and the banjo vernacular? Why is the flute refined and the banjo rustic? Who decided these categories, and what purposes do they serve?

Historical Precedents and Failures

The banjo is not the first "inappropriate" instrument to enter art music. The saxophone, invented in the 1840s, struggled for over a century to gain full acceptance in classical music despite significant repertoire from composers like Debussy, Glazunov, and Ibert. The saxophone carried jazz associations that made it suspect in academic contexts, too popular to be serious, too new to have established legitimacy.

The guitar faced similar resistance. Despite a rich solo repertoire and the advocacy of performers like Andrés Segovia, the guitar remained peripheral to mainstream chamber music throughout much of the 20th century. Its associations with popular music, folk traditions, and flamenco marked it as somehow less serious than keyboard or bowed string instruments.

But the banjo's problem is more acute. The saxophone eventually accumulated enough art music repertoire to establish alternative associations. The guitar's Renaissance and Baroque pedigree provided historical legitimacy. The banjo has neither of these escape routes. Its history is too American, too vernacular, too entangled with cultural forms that remain outside the European concert tradition.

Some composers have attempted to "elevate" the banjo by writing in conventional classical styles, treating it as simply another plucked string instrument that happens to have a metal head. These attempts generally fail because they misunderstand the instrument's power. The banjo's value in contemporary composition is not that it can imitate classical guitar technique. Its value is precisely in its refusal to do so, in its insistence on remaining itself.

Case Study: The Trio as Collision

Consider a hypothetical trio for flute, banjo, and cello. Not a real work, but a thought experiment about what happens when these instruments occupy the same sonic space.

The flute enters with a long, sustained tone. The cello provides harmonic support with slow-moving bass line. This is familiar territory. We know how to listen to this. We've been trained by centuries of flute and cello repertoire.

Then the banjo enters.

The attack is sharper than anything the flute can produce, more percussive than the cello's pizzicato. The pitch is clear, but the timbre refuses to merge with the other instruments. It stands apart, alien, insisting on its difference.

The listener's ear attempts to process this anomaly. Is it accompaniment? The attack is too prominent. Is it melody? The sustain is too brief. Is it percussion? The pitch is too defined. The banjo occupies a category that doesn't exist in the listener's established taxonomy of chamber music roles.

This creates cognitive dissonance, a gap between expectation and experience. The ear keeps trying to place the banjo in a familiar context and keeps failing. This failure is not a bug. It's the feature.

The trio cannot achieve blend in the conventional sense. The instruments remain distinct, separate, operating in parallel rather than merging into unified ensemble texture. This separateness reveals that blend itself is a constructed aesthetic value, not a natural acoustic fact. We've been taught to prize blend, but the banjo asks: why? What happens if we abandon blend entirely and embrace collision instead?

Estrangement as Compositional Method

Russian Formalist critic Viktor Shklovsky coined the term "ostranenie," usually translated as "estrangement" or "defamiliarization." He argued that art's function is to make the familiar strange, to disrupt automatic perception and force us to see things anew.

The banjo operates as an instrument of ostranenie within chamber music. It takes the familiar forms of art music, the established gestures and textures, and makes them strange by refusing to participate in their conventions. This refusal is not failure but revelation.

When a composer writes for banjo in art music context, they are not simply expanding the palette of available timbres. They are engaging in a form of institutional critique, questioning the boundaries that determine what counts as serious music, what instruments belong in concert halls, what cultural traditions get classified as art versus entertainment.

This critique operates through the ears. The listener experiences the banjo's strangeness not as abstract concept but as sonic fact. The instrument's bright, nasal attack interrupts the flow of conventional chamber music texture in ways that cannot be intellectualized away. You hear the disruption before you theorize it.

The Composer's Choice

Why would a composer deliberately introduce this kind of disruption? What artistic goals justify the banjo problem?

Several possibilities emerge:

Timbral Expansion: The banjo genuinely offers sonic qualities unavailable from guitar, mandolin, or other plucked strings. Its attack characteristics, harmonic spectrum, and decay envelope are unique. Composers interested in exploring the full range of acoustic possibilities find in the banjo a relatively untapped resource.

Cultural Critique: Composers working at the intersection of classical and vernacular traditions use the banjo to question hierarchies of cultural value. The instrument's presence asks who gets to make art music and whose traditions count as legitimate sources for composition.

Defamiliarization: Composers seeking to disrupt listener expectations and force active rather than passive listening use the banjo's estranging effect deliberately. The goal is not comfort but cognitive engagement, not blend but productive friction.

Authenticity: Some composers, particularly those with roots in American folk traditions, use the banjo as authentic personal voice rather than exotic addition. For these composers, the banjo's vernacular associations are not problems to overcome but resources to embrace.

Each of these motivations leads to different compositional strategies, different ways of integrating (or refusing to integrate) the banjo into ensemble texture.

Performance Challenges

The banjo problem extends beyond composition into performance. Musicians trained in classical traditions often lack familiarity with banjo technique, while experienced banjo players may struggle with the precision and notational complexity of contemporary scores.

This technical divide mirrors the cultural divide the instrument embodies. Classical training emphasizes certain values: precise intonation, evenness of tone, seamless legato. Bluegrass and old-time traditions emphasize different values: rhythmic drive, ornamentation, improvisatory flexibility. These value systems don't contradict each other, but they don't easily merge either.

Performers attempting to bridge this divide must develop bilingual fluency, understanding both the technical demands of contemporary notation and the idiomatic possibilities of the instrument itself. The most successful performances come from musicians who resist the temptation to make the banjo sound like something else, who embrace its strangeness rather than apologizing for it.

The Audience Question

How do audiences receive this deliberate estrangement? The answer varies wildly depending on context and expectation.

In experimental music venues, where audiences arrive prepared for the unexpected, the banjo's presence may register as interesting timbral choice but not shocking disruption. These listeners have already suspended conventional genre expectations.

In traditional chamber music venues, the response can be more complicated. Some listeners experience the banjo as refreshing intrusion, a welcome disruption of overly refined atmospheres. Others hear it as intrusive, a violation of the aesthetic contract they expected when purchasing tickets to a chamber music concert.

This divided response is itself revealing. It demonstrates that the banjo problem is not actually about the banjo. It's about audience expectations, about what we think belongs in concert halls, about whose musical traditions get classified as art and whose remain categorized as entertainment.

The banjo simply makes these usually invisible distinctions audible. It forces the question: what are we really listening for when we attend concerts? Confirmation of our existing taste? Comfort in familiar sounds? Or genuine encounter with the strange, the disruptive, the not-yet-assimilated?

Beyond the Banjo

While this essay has focused on the banjo specifically, the principles extend to any "inappropriate" instrumentation in art music contexts. The accordion, the harmonica, the ukulele, the steel drum, all carry similar potential for productive estrangement. Each brings its own cultural associations, its own sonic signature that resists absorption into conventional ensemble textures.

Composers working at the edges of established practice understand that instrumentation is never neutral. Every choice of instrument is simultaneously a choice about cultural positioning, about which traditions to invoke, about what kind of listening to demand from audiences.

The most interesting contemporary music often emerges from these friction points, these moments when incompatible traditions collide and neither fully absorbs the other. The resulting music cannot be easily categorized. It exists in the productive gap between classical and vernacular, between art and entertainment, between familiar and strange.

The Problem That Isn't

To call this "the banjo problem" is, finally, a misnomer. The banjo poses no problem that doesn't already exist in the structures of musical categorization and cultural value. The instrument simply makes visible what was always there: the arbitrary nature of our distinctions between serious and popular, art and entertainment, refined and rustic.

What if we reframed the question entirely? Not "how do we solve the banjo problem?" but "what does the banjo reveal about the limitations of our existing frameworks?"

Seen this way, the banjo becomes not intrusion but invitation. It invites composers to question inherited assumptions about appropriate instrumentation. It invites performers to develop new technical vocabularies that don't erase vernacular traditions in service of classical precision. It invites audiences to expand their definitions of what counts as art music, what deserves attention in concert contexts.

The banjo's estranging presence reveals that our categories were always provisional, always constructed, always open to renegotiation. The instrument doesn't create disorder. It reveals the artificiality of our imposed order.

Practical Applications

For composers considering unconventional instrumentation, the banjo offers several lessons:

Embrace the estrangement: Don't try to make the unconventional instrument sound conventional. Its value lies precisely in its refusal to blend, its insistence on remaining audibly different.

Consider cultural context: Unconventional instruments carry cultural associations that cannot be ignored or transcended through technique alone. These associations are part of the material you're working with, not obstacles to overcome.

Respect technical traditions: Understanding the idiomatic techniques of vernacular instruments enriches possibilities rather than limiting them. The goal is not to erase tradition but to place it in dialogue with other traditions.

Demand listening: Estranging instrumentation forces active listening. Use this deliberately. Structure your music to reward the cognitive work audiences must perform to process unfamiliar sonic combinations.

Coda

The banjo sits in rehearsal, waiting. The flute and cello are warming up, running through familiar technical passages, preparing to play together in ways they've played hundreds of times before.

The banjo will not play that way. It cannot. Its metal head and bright attack, its cultural freight and timbral signature, all resist the smooth integration the other instruments can achieve. When the trio begins, something will break. Something should break.

That breaking is not failure. It's the sound of categories cracking open, of boundaries becoming permeable, of the familiar becoming strange enough to hear again.

The banjo problem is not a problem. It's a proposition: what if we listened differently? What if we abandoned the demand for seamless blend and embraced productive friction instead? What if the goal of ensemble playing was not unity but dialogue, not merger but conversation between irreducibly different voices?

The banjo has been asking these questions since the first composer had the audacity to write it into a chamber work. We're still learning to hear what it's saying.

The disruption continues. The estrangement persists. The banjo, bright and nasal and impossible to ignore, keeps refusing to be anything other than exactly what it is.

This refusal is its gift to contemporary music: the reminder that strangeness, friction, and unresolved difference might be values worth preserving rather than problems to solve.

The trio begins. The banjo enters. Everything familiar becomes strange.

Listen.

The Composer as Interrogator of Expression



The Composer as Interrogator of Expression

To speak of expression today is already to step into compromised terrain. Expression presumes sincerity, assumes transparency, imagines a direct passage between inner state and outward form. The work under consideration rejects this passage entirely. It proposes instead a different role for the composer: not as facilitator of expression, nor as architect of affect, but as interrogator. What is staged is not feeling, but suspicion. Not communication, but friction.

“I do not ask the performer to interpret the face. I ask them to interrogate it.”

This distinction is not rhetorical. Interpretation presumes goodwill. Interrogation presumes deceit.

The portrait, once placed on the page, is stripped of its human alibi. It ceases to function as likeness and becomes object. Instrument. Evidence. The face does not represent a person; it performs as a proxy for identity itself, a stand-in that must be treated as unreliable. Assume it lies. Assume it is not what it claims to be. Assume, finally, that it is you. Not as autobiography, but as structural condition.

Here the composer does not offer expressive content to be realized. Instead, they install a situation. A face is positioned, not explained. No backstory, no dramaturgical reassurance. The performer is left alone with the image, and the image refuses to stabilize. It watches without responding. It accuses without speaking. It invites projection while withholding consent.



This is where the work begins.

Once embedded in the score, the portrait becomes a functional device. It does not decorate the notation; it contaminates it. It alters the phenomenology of reading. The performer is no longer alone with symbols and gestures, but with a gaze that interrupts neutrality. The page becomes a site of exposure. The score ceases to be an abstract field and becomes a room in which someone is already present.

Responses vary, and these variations are not incidental; they are diagnostic. Some performers weep. Others ask if the image can be removed. They describe discomfort, distraction, an uncanny sensation of being observed by someone they failed to understand, or worse, someone who understands them too well. The request for removal is telling. It is not the difficulty of execution that troubles them, but the collapse of distance. The performer can no longer retreat into technique, into professionalism, into the safety of interpretation.


They are implicated.

“I tell them that’s the point.”

The composer’s refusal to mitigate this discomfort is not cruelty; it is precision. The work insists that expression is not something one safely produces, but something one risks being undone by. By withholding instructions, the composer denies the performer the familiar scaffolding of intention. There is no guidance on how to feel, what to convey, or who the image is supposed to be. This absence is not a lack; it is an active pressure.



There are no instructions. Only placement.

Placement, here, functions as compositional force. The image is not explained because explanation would domesticate it. Instead, it is situated, framed, allowed to exert its gravity. The score does not tell the performer what to do with the portrait; it forces them to decide whether they can proceed at all. The act of performance becomes an ethical negotiation rather than an expressive one.

This is why the score is not a map. A map reassures. A map promises arrival. This score stages collisions.

Sound against silence.
Identity against absence.
Legibility against suggestion.

Each collision is unresolved. Sound does not conquer silence; it exposes it. Identity does not assert itself; it fractures against the realization that the face might be empty, might be a mask, might be an echo. Legibility does not clarify meaning; it destabilizes it by suggesting that what can be read is precisely what should not be trusted.



In this framework, the performer is no longer an interpreter but a participant in an experiment on expression itself. What happens when expression is no longer authorized by intention? What happens when the face on the page does not ask to be understood, but demands to be questioned? What happens when the performer recognizes their own strategies of avoidance, projection, and control reflected back at them?

The composer, then, is not offering a language, but setting a trap. Not a trap designed to catch the performer, but one designed to catch habits: the habit of sincerity, the habit of empathy, the habit of assuming that expression is a virtue rather than a problem.

This is curatorial composition. The work curates conditions under which meaning misbehaves. It arranges objects, images, and absences so that the performer cannot simply pass through them unchanged. The portrait is not there to humanize the score; it is there to estrange it. To remind the performer that every act of expression is also an act of substitution, displacement, and possible falsification.


In this sense, the work does not ask, “What does this mean?”
It asks, “What are you doing when you try to make it mean?”

The answer is never stable. And that instability is the work’s most precise achievement.

B Flat trumpet. Pedal Tones.

 

This is a score for B Flat Trumpet. Pedal tones only.

Let that sit for a moment.

Pedal tones are the notes a trumpet is not supposed to produce. They live below the instrument's practical range, in the register where the physics of the brass tube and the physics of the human body negotiate an agreement that neither party is fully comfortable with. They are not extended technique in the fashionable sense. They are extended existence. The trumpet playing a pedal tone is not performing. It is confessing.

This page is where that confession happens.

Look at what the notation is doing to the single stave running through the center of the page. It is not supporting the notation. It is barely surviving it. The stave is a horizon line across which five extraordinary events are occurring simultaneously above and below, each one orbiting the line the way weather systems orbit a pressure front, each one named.

Intra by ColloSurria. The first event cloud, rendered in burnt orange and deep blue, is not a chord cluster or a multiphonic. It is an atmospheric condition. ColloSurria is a word I coined through my Brand Acumen's https://brandacumen.co/ neological process for exactly this phenomenon: the state of colliding tonal atmospheres that cannot be separately identified because their boundaries have dissolved into each other before the ear can locate them. The notation inside the cloud is real. The cloud is also real. Both are instructions. Neither is metaphor.

Abtoxicalleraphy. The second event above the stave is the one that required the longest naming process. Abtoxicalleraphy describes the specific somatic condition of a brass player producing a pedal tone in the extreme low register while simultaneously maintaining embouchure control sufficient for the notated pitch content inside the event. It is toxic to the body in the way that any act of sustained physical extremity is toxic. It is also therapeutic in the way that sustained physical extremity always is. The word needed to hold both truths without resolving the contradiction and it does.

PISTO, RELECTIO, NEVITerseo. This vertical text cluster, rotating around its own axis in the lower center of the page, is the score's pharmacopeia in concentrated form. These are not performance instructions. They are not dynamics. They are states of being that the performer must inhabit before the notation can be executed. PISTO: the compressed interior pressure of the breath before release. RELECTIO: the act of reading something you wrote and no longer recognizing it as yours. NEVITerseo: the specific dizziness that arrives approximately forty seconds into a sustained pedal tone when the oxygen balance in the blood has shifted enough to alter perception without yet altering consciousness. Every trumpeter who has played in this register knows this state. This is the first score that names it.

WHOLE. The black rectangle at the lower right contains a single word in white. Not a note name. Not a duration. Not a dynamic. WHOLE. In the tradition of Ruscha's word paintings this is the score at its most reduced and most complete: the entire instruction for the final event compressed into a single word that is simultaneously a note value, a philosophical proposition, a demand, and a joke. The notation that follows it to the right, the cluster of accidentals and note heads accumulating around an open whole note, is the elaboration of that single word into something playable. But WHOLE came first. The notation is the footnote.

AnsevR and DisceRna-Poli-T. The two event clouds at the lower center and upper right are the score's Carson moments, the typography refusing to hold still, the letters rotating and fragmenting and partially dissolving the way David Carson dissolved type when he understood that legibility was a convention rather than a requirement, and that breaking it produced not confusion but a different and more honest kind of reading. AnsevR names the specific quality of resonance that a pedal tone produces in a large acoustic space, the sound returning altered, as if the room has edited it. DisceRna-Poli-T describes the perceptual condition of the listener rather than the performer, the moment when a sustained very low frequency ceases to be heard as pitch and begins to be felt as pressure, the threshold where music becomes weather.

And then there is the Thomas Demand dimension of this page.

Demand builds architectural models of real spaces and then photographs them, the photograph revealing its own constructedness only slowly, the surfaces too perfect, the shadows too even, the paper grain eventually visible as the wrong kind of grain for the space it is replicating. This score does the same thing. The notational elements are real notation. The stave is a real stave. The clef is a real clef. But the event clouds are not illustrations. They are not generated by any conventional notation software. They are constructions, physical in their own register, that reveal their constructedness only after extended looking. The score is a model of a musical event that has not yet occurred, and the photograph of that model is this page.

The pedal tone is the note the trumpet makes when it stops pretending.

This is the score for that note.

Saturday, November 21, 2026

These Scores Do Not Ask to be Played. They Ask to be Reckoned With.

 


Mental Mechanics: The Performer as Disrupted Executor

My notational strategy of placing signs within, under, next to, and inside one another functions as a dysfunctional transmission. What results is a kind of mechanical metaphor for the failure of seamless communication. The performer is rendered a subjective engine, working through layers of visual obfuscation, symbolic misdirection, and embodied presence.

This disjunction is key: The scores operate on a logic of material compatibility, not performative comfort. The signs, images, textures, and figures used are relationally coherent within the architecture of the score itself, but may resist translation into performative gesture. This is a radical proposition: that the score-machine exists not to be executed, but to be inhabited, like one of Roussel’s linguistic devices or Picabia’s eroticized camshafts.

From Notation to Imagination Machine

In this framework, the score becomes a new kind of imagination machine, one in which the laws of musical grammar have been bent to accommodate psychological interference, bodily proximity, and material seduction. This is not notation for performance.  It is notation as experience, notation as artifact, notation as site of metaphysical experimentation.

Much like Duchamp’s bachelor machine, the scores embody a tension between desire and delay, between symbolic motion and erotic failure. They perform not just as texts to be read or sounds to be made, but as complexes of action, image, and concept. The machine no longer produces.  It suggests, interrupts, withholds.

Toward a New Poetics of Notation

In this work, we see a revival, not of function, but of metaphysical invention. The score becomes not a vessel but a mechanism of contradiction. A chamber of relations. A surface of layered symbolic interference. Like Roussel’s instruments, it is full of language disguised as device; like Duchamp’s glass, it is full of ghosted motion and deferred consummation. And like Picabia’s drawings, it is irreverent, recursive, and iconoclastic.

These scores do not ask to be played. They ask to be reckoned with. To be understood not through the hands, but through the eyes, the skin, the resistance of thought to sound. In this, they are notational descendants of a long lineage of impossible machines—machines that seduce not with their efficiency, but with their refusal to function on anyone’s terms but their own.


A Very Early Concept. Notational Simplicity, But Hidden Complication. (By No Means a Finished Score)


 

Four, Twice

Some notes on Clarionista

By Bil Smith

The melody in Clarionista is the plainest thing I've put on paper in a long time, and I feel oddly defensive about it. Treble clef, one flat, 4/4, a repeat at each end, a whole rest. It rises, peaks, and comes down again. Sit at a piano with it and you'd have it in a minute.

My scores usually go the other way. I once wrote that notation should frighten you a little, and I still believe it. This page doesn't frighten anybody if all you read is the notes. So whatever it costs the player has moved out to the edges, into a set of numbers that I want to go through one at a time. I don't think they get looked at closely on a first pass. I'm including myself in that.

Start at the top. There are rows of six-digit counters, zero-padded the way a numbering stamp or a till roll prints them, and each row has a date in front of it: 14.03.78, 15.03.78, 16.03.78, 17.03.78. Day, month, year, the European order.

On the first day the count goes 000001, 000002, 000003, 000004, 000004, and on up to 000010. The four is printed twice. The second day does the same thing once, at 000013, and finishes on 000020. If you were the person reconciling this you'd circle the doubles and keep going. One slip a day isn't much.

The third day is where I'd stop and put the pen down. 000022 appears twice and 000023 doesn't appear at all. 25 is doubled. 000036 sits between 000026 and 000027, nowhere near where it belongs. The fourth day begins at 000031, drops back to 000022 and 000023, which are yesterday's numbers, doubles 35, doubles 36, and climbs to 000040. Underneath, 17.03.78 is stamped a second time with a single 000031 after it, and nothing more.

I go back and forth on that second 17.03.78. Some days it reads like a fresh start that didn't take. Other days it looks like somebody hit the date stamp twice and walked off. I can't settle it, and I've stopped trying.

Then there's the SUMME row (German for total): 000020, 000040, an empty cell, 000060, 000080, 000100. Clean twenties. Whoever wrote them wasn't looking at the entries above, or was and didn't care. The empty box in the middle is the one place where a number just wasn't supplied, and I trust it more than anything else in the ledger.

Running up the right margin, turned on its side, are three sums. Work them yourself if you like. I'd rather you didn't take my word for it.

16 + 17 + 18 + 29 + 29 − 219 + 24 + 20 is written as 90. It comes to −66.

At 11.20: 21 + 27 + 23 + 28 − 24 + 25 + 20 is written as 115. It comes to 120.

At 11.40: 26 + 27 + 28 + 23 + 29 − 28 + 39 + 30 is written as 140. It comes to 174.

The −219 bothers me most. Everything around it is a small two-digit number, then this, and the total doesn't register it at all. The other two sums are off by less, but look at what they claim: 90, 115, 140, each one twenty-five more than the last. With 11.20 and 11.40 written above them like times on a clock, it's hard for me not to see someone checking a figure through a morning and writing down the figure that was expected of them.

(Anyone know Hanne Darboven?)

That's my reading. The page doesn't say who did it or why. But an error that keeps landing on a neat schedule doesn't behave like an accident, and I haven't found another way to read it.

The fractions over the notes are all sixteenths: 17/16, 19/16, 23/16, 25/16, 29/16, 29/16, 23/16, 37/16, 31/16, 37/16, 41/16, 43/16. Anyone who works with the overtone series will read them as partials over a low fundamental, with 16 as home. 17/16 is about 105 cents up. 23/16 is around 628, which no keyboard will give you. 43/16 is past the octave, close to 1712. The ±1/4 arrows on the noteheads are the practical side of it, how far to bend each written pitch toward its partial.

Look at the numerators by themselves for a second. 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43. That's every prime from 17 to 43, with none skipped, plus a 25. The 25 is the only number in the list that isn't prime, and it sits fourth, which sends me straight back to the ledger, where four is the first number printed twice. I'm not going to tell you that was planned. I'm telling you what I see when I look.

(At this point, if you don't know Hanne Darboven, stop reading this)

25/16 has something else in it. It's 5/4 times 5/4, two pure major thirds stacked. Hold on to that for the top of the arc.

Over the whole melody there's a long curve, drawn in several strokes, from 19/16 to 43/16. At its highest point is a column of +1/4 markings, nine of them, with a single −1/4 on top. Nine quarter tones up is about 450 cents. One back down leaves 400, which is an equal-tempered major third. So the phrase spends its whole length on primes and odd partials and arrives, at the peak, at the most ordinary interval there is, in its tempered form, about fourteen cents wide of the pure 5/4 tucked inside that 25.

The lone −1/4 is the mark I keep coming back to. Nine instructions to go higher, then one small step back at the very top. To me it looks like someone correcting an overstatement by the least amount that will pass. The ledger hides its corrections. The arc writes every one of them out, where the player has no choice but to read them.

There are a few things on the left side I can't account for very well. A gray rectangle, worn and scratched, something like an old stamp pad or a patch of paper that's been erased too often. Bits of ruled line near it, corners and short verticals, which might be the beginning of a drawing of a building. Wavy lines between the ledger rows, the kind you'd use to strike out an empty space.

I don't know what happened between the 14th and the 17th of March 1978, and the score doesn't say. It's easy to imagine a ticket office, or a goods yard, or a hospital desk at night, and every time I do it I notice I'm filling in a story the paper never offered. Readers will do the same, and they're welcome to. I'd only ask that nobody mistake the story for information.

The piece is dated Thanksgiving week, 2026, forty-eight years after the ledger. I know what that holiday asks people to do, which is sit down and count what they have. I'm leaving that alone.

There's no instruction to the player about any of the numbers. You can play the tune and let the margins sit there. Or you can let them get under your skin, so that every bent pitch feels like adjusting a figure. My guess is that most performances will land somewhere in between, and not in the same place twice. I'd like to hear both kinds.