Recessive Tablatures: Toward a Deconstructive Notion of the Musical Score
To speak of Recessive Tablatures in the Derridean sense is to evoke a site of multiplicity and différance—a score no longer constrained by the rigid binaries of prescriptive and interpretative, but one that operates as a field of constant deferral, of interstitial spaces where meaning and sound dissolve, reconstitute, and dissolve again. The recessive quality here is not merely one of subordination or withdrawal but is a deliberate and generative retreat, where what is withheld becomes as potent as what is given, if not more so. In this way, Recessive Tablatures are not just a notational system but a philosophical interrogation of notation itself, a questioning of its origins, its functions, and its possibilities.
 |
| "Detlin's Baby" for Alto Flute |
The Trace of the Score: Erasure, Presence, and Absence
The concept of Recessive Tablatures begins with a fundamental premise: that every mark on the page—the note, the line, the symbol—carries within it the trace of what it excludes. The traditional musical score, in its seemingly authoritative clarity, is a structure of violence, a suppression of the unmarked, the silenced possibilities that exist at its margins. Recessive Tablatures, by contrast, make space for these silences. They posit a score where absence is inscribed as presence, where what is erased leaves its ghostly imprint, its irreducible remainder.
Take, for instance, a fragment of notation that has been intentionally degraded or obscured—an eighth note whose stem is erased, whose placement on the staff is uncertain. In the language of Recessive Tablatures, this erasure is not a void but a productive gap, a site where the performer must actively negotiate meaning. The trace of the erased note lingers, not as an absence to be lamented but as a presence to be inhabited, explored, and even celebrated.
A Hypothetical Example: The Dissolving Bar Line
Imagine a score where the traditional bar lines are rendered in fading gradients, moving from bold opacity to translucent shadow. The first bar is clear and authoritative; the last is barely visible, almost a memory. The performer, encountering this fading structure, must decide: Does the dissolution signal a move toward rubato, an abandonment of strict meter? Or does it invite a hyper-precise adherence to the remnants of structure? The bar line, in its recession, becomes an open-ended question, a site of différance where meaning is perpetually deferred.
Writing Under Erasure: Notation as Palimpsest
In Recessive Tablatures, the score functions as a palimpsest, a surface where multiple layers of meaning coexist, overlap, and obscure one another. The composer, rather than presenting a single, unified text, inscribes a series of provisional gestures, each of which points beyond itself to a network of potential interpretations. The performer, in turn, becomes an archaeologist of sorts, excavating these layers and deciding which to privilege, which to ignore, and which to let linger in the background.
A Hypothetical Example: Layered Transparency
Consider a score printed on multiple sheets of translucent vellum. The top layer contains a traditional melody line; beneath it, faintly visible, are alternative pitches and rhythms that suggest possible embellishments or deviations. A third layer might include abstract graphic symbols, and a fourth, textual cues like "hesitate" or "disperse." The performer, manipulating these layers, creates a dynamic reading of the score, choosing which elements to foreground and which to let recede. The act of performance becomes an act of writing, a re-inscription of the score that is unique to each iteration.
The Economy of Différance: Recessive Temporality
Time, in Recessive Tablatures, is no longer a linear progression from one moment to the next but a field of simultaneous possibilities, a temporality that folds back on itself and opens outward in all directions. The score, rather than dictating a fixed sequence of events, suggests temporal flows that are fluid, recursive, and indeterminate.
A Hypothetical Example: Temporal Loops
A passage in the score is marked with overlapping rhythmic structures—triplets in one layer, duplets in another, and free-floating accelerandi in a third. The performer is instructed to "weave" these rhythms together, not in strict alignment but in a way that allows them to resonate against one another. The result is a temporal texture that feels both anchored and unmoored, a pulse that is perpetually becoming but never fully arrives.
This temporal indeterminacy aligns with Derrida's notion of the "future anterior"—a sense of time that is always already in flux, where the past is rewritten by the present, and the future is haunted by the traces of what has come before.
The Role of the Performer: From Executor to Interpreter
In the world of traditional notation, the performer is often positioned as a subordinate figure, a medium through which the composer's intentions are realized. Recessive Tablatures disrupt this hierarchy, positioning the performer as a co-creator, an active participant in the construction of meaning.
A Hypothetical Example: Textual Resonances
A passage in the score contains fragments of text: "fractured clarity," "oscillating shadow," "vanish toward brightness." These phrases are not instructions but resonances, verbal textures that invite the performer to consider not just what to play but how to inhabit the music. The text functions as a horizon of meaning, a field of possibilities that the performer must navigate.
Toward an Interdisciplinary Notation
Recessive Tablatures do not exist in isolation; they draw on a broad range of influences from art, architecture, and literature. The score becomes a site of interdisciplinary exchange, where the visual, the spatial, and the textual converge to create a new mode of musical communication.
A Hypothetical Example: The Architectural Score
A section of the score is laid out not in traditional staves but as a spatial diagram—a series of arcs, lines, and nodes that suggest relationships between musical ideas. The performer, interpreting this diagram, must consider not just the sound but the space it inhabits, the way it interacts with the physical environment of the performance.
The Future of Recessive Tablatures
Recessive Tablatures represent a radical rethinking of what a score can be. By embracing ambiguity, deferral, and multiplicity, they open up new possibilities for both composition and performance. They challenge us to reconsider the very nature of musical meaning, to see the score not as a static text but as a living, breathing field of potential.
In this way, Recessive Tablatures are not just a notation system but a philosophical proposition, a call to rethink the relationships between composer, performer, and audience, between presence and absence, between what is written and what is yet to be imagined. They remind us that music, like language, is always more than it appears—always receding, always becoming, always arriving.
No comments:
Post a Comment