Saturday, November 21, 2026

A Very Early Concept. Notational Simplicity, But Hidden Complication. (By No Means a Finished Score)


 

Four, Twice

Some notes on Clarionista

By Bil Smith

The melody in Clarionista is the plainest thing I've put on paper in a long time, and I feel oddly defensive about it. Treble clef, one flat, 4/4, a repeat at each end, a whole rest. It rises, peaks, and comes down again. Sit at a piano with it and you'd have it in a minute.

My scores usually go the other way. I once wrote that notation should frighten you a little, and I still believe it. This page doesn't frighten anybody if all you read is the notes. So whatever it costs the player has moved out to the edges, into a set of numbers that I want to go through one at a time. I don't think they get looked at closely on a first pass. I'm including myself in that.

Start at the top. There are rows of six-digit counters, zero-padded the way a numbering stamp or a till roll prints them, and each row has a date in front of it: 14.03.78, 15.03.78, 16.03.78, 17.03.78. Day, month, year, the European order.

On the first day the count goes 000001, 000002, 000003, 000004, 000004, and on up to 000010. The four is printed twice. The second day does the same thing once, at 000013, and finishes on 000020. If you were the person reconciling this you'd circle the doubles and keep going. One slip a day isn't much.

The third day is where I'd stop and put the pen down. 000022 appears twice and 000023 doesn't appear at all. 25 is doubled. 000036 sits between 000026 and 000027, nowhere near where it belongs. The fourth day begins at 000031, drops back to 000022 and 000023, which are yesterday's numbers, doubles 35, doubles 36, and climbs to 000040. Underneath, 17.03.78 is stamped a second time with a single 000031 after it, and nothing more.

I go back and forth on that second 17.03.78. Some days it reads like a fresh start that didn't take. Other days it looks like somebody hit the date stamp twice and walked off. I can't settle it, and I've stopped trying.

Then there's the SUMME row (German for total): 000020, 000040, an empty cell, 000060, 000080, 000100. Clean twenties. Whoever wrote them wasn't looking at the entries above, or was and didn't care. The empty box in the middle is the one place where a number just wasn't supplied, and I trust it more than anything else in the ledger.

Running up the right margin, turned on its side, are three sums. Work them yourself if you like. I'd rather you didn't take my word for it.

16 + 17 + 18 + 29 + 29 − 219 + 24 + 20 is written as 90. It comes to −66.

At 11.20: 21 + 27 + 23 + 28 − 24 + 25 + 20 is written as 115. It comes to 120.

At 11.40: 26 + 27 + 28 + 23 + 29 − 28 + 39 + 30 is written as 140. It comes to 174.

The −219 bothers me most. Everything around it is a small two-digit number, then this, and the total doesn't register it at all. The other two sums are off by less, but look at what they claim: 90, 115, 140, each one twenty-five more than the last. With 11.20 and 11.40 written above them like times on a clock, it's hard for me not to see someone checking a figure through a morning and writing down the figure that was expected of them.

(Anyone know Hanne Darboven?)

That's my reading. The page doesn't say who did it or why. But an error that keeps landing on a neat schedule doesn't behave like an accident, and I haven't found another way to read it.

The fractions over the notes are all sixteenths: 17/16, 19/16, 23/16, 25/16, 29/16, 29/16, 23/16, 37/16, 31/16, 37/16, 41/16, 43/16. Anyone who works with the overtone series will read them as partials over a low fundamental, with 16 as home. 17/16 is about 105 cents up. 23/16 is around 628, which no keyboard will give you. 43/16 is past the octave, close to 1712. The ±1/4 arrows on the noteheads are the practical side of it, how far to bend each written pitch toward its partial.

Look at the numerators by themselves for a second. 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43. That's every prime from 17 to 43, with none skipped, plus a 25. The 25 is the only number in the list that isn't prime, and it sits fourth, which sends me straight back to the ledger, where four is the first number printed twice. I'm not going to tell you that was planned. I'm telling you what I see when I look.

(At this point, if you don't know Hanne Darboven, stop reading this)

25/16 has something else in it. It's 5/4 times 5/4, two pure major thirds stacked. Hold on to that for the top of the arc.

Over the whole melody there's a long curve, drawn in several strokes, from 19/16 to 43/16. At its highest point is a column of +1/4 markings, nine of them, with a single −1/4 on top. Nine quarter tones up is about 450 cents. One back down leaves 400, which is an equal-tempered major third. So the phrase spends its whole length on primes and odd partials and arrives, at the peak, at the most ordinary interval there is, in its tempered form, about fourteen cents wide of the pure 5/4 tucked inside that 25.

The lone −1/4 is the mark I keep coming back to. Nine instructions to go higher, then one small step back at the very top. To me it looks like someone correcting an overstatement by the least amount that will pass. The ledger hides its corrections. The arc writes every one of them out, where the player has no choice but to read them.

There are a few things on the left side I can't account for very well. A gray rectangle, worn and scratched, something like an old stamp pad or a patch of paper that's been erased too often. Bits of ruled line near it, corners and short verticals, which might be the beginning of a drawing of a building. Wavy lines between the ledger rows, the kind you'd use to strike out an empty space.

I don't know what happened between the 14th and the 17th of March 1978, and the score doesn't say. It's easy to imagine a ticket office, or a goods yard, or a hospital desk at night, and every time I do it I notice I'm filling in a story the paper never offered. Readers will do the same, and they're welcome to. I'd only ask that nobody mistake the story for information.

The piece is dated Thanksgiving week, 2026, forty-eight years after the ledger. I know what that holiday asks people to do, which is sit down and count what they have. I'm leaving that alone.

There's no instruction to the player about any of the numbers. You can play the tune and let the margins sit there. Or you can let them get under your skin, so that every bent pitch feels like adjusting a figure. My guess is that most performances will land somewhere in between, and not in the same place twice. I'd like to hear both kinds.

Selepiton for Alto Flute. A score, a sleep study and an obituary



Thirty Seconds Without Air

Selepiton for Alto Flute, a sleep study and an obituary

By Bil Smith

Link to PDF

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1AtWZTlCATZIbNMAp1f2RsvvQZr_Z8dfR/view?usp=sharing

The first number in this score is 34.2. Per hour.

That is an apnea-hypopnea index, the count of times an hour a sleeping body stops breathing or nearly stops. It sits in a box on page one, in clinic type, next to a sleep efficiency of 71% and a lowest blood oxygen of 79%. Below the boxes, a sleep technician describes an old man who arrived on foot with his own pillow and a railroad watch he would not take off. Below her note, the notation begins.

I have spent years arguing that a score can be a crime scene, a pharmacy label, a credit rating, a weather log. This one is a medical chart, and then it is a death notice. I want to explain why I think that is the most honest place a piece of music has ever started.

What is on the pages

Five pages, and none of them looks like a flute part.

Page one is the summary of findings. Page two is a hypnogram, the staircase graph a sleep lab draws of one night, stage by stage, 808 thirty-second steps from lights out at 22:47 to lights on at 05:31, with nine numbered events the technician wrote up in the margins. Page three is a single epoch at 02:40: eight channels of raw signal, brain and eyes and chin and airflow, chest, oxygen, heart, and a microphone. Page four is the man talking in his sleep. Page five is his obituary, printed as one long narrow strip with a railroad track running down its edge.

The notation enters on the first two pages, underneath the clinical material, the way a second sleeper lies under the covers. Dense clusters of noteheads, microtonal accidentals with arrows, beams stacked like ties on a siding, a small curl of cloud, circled numbers. It is not attached to anything in the report. It sits below it, in the white space a clinic leaves for a signature that never arrives.

The page with no notes

Page three has no notation on it at all. I left it that way on purpose, and it is the page performers ask me about first.

Look at the airflow channel. A sine wave, two breaths, then a flat line from six seconds to twenty-eight. Twenty-two seconds in which, as the technician writes, nothing passes in or out of him. Directly below it, the chest and abdomen keep heaving the whole time. The body is trying. The throat has closed.

That is a score. It has an exact duration and a contradiction built into it that no articulation mark of mine could improve on: two lines that should move together, one working and one stopped. Above them, the EEG gives one second of spindle, which the technician compares to a pencil tapped twice on a desk. Below them, the microphone shows thirty small spikes in thirty seconds. That is the watch. It never misses.

I am asking the flutist to read this page the way a clinician reads it, slowly, one channel at a time, and then to play what they found. Some will play the flat line as silence. Some will play it as air with no tone, which is what it literally is. A third might hold one key down for twenty-two seconds without blowing and listen to the pad close. I have no objection to any of them. The page does not tell you what to do. It tells you what happened.

A breathing instrument for a man who stopped breathing

Why the alto flute? Because there is no instrument more honest about breath. A flutist cannot hide an inhale. Every phrase ends where the lungs end, and the alto, with its long tube and its slow, cool sound, makes the cost of air audible. You hear it run out.

So the piece asks a player whose whole craft is the management of breath to perform a night in which breath kept failing. Two hundred and eleven arousals. Each one is the body jerking itself back into air. The flutist has to decide, phrase by phrase, whether to breathe where he did not, or to stop where he stopped.

I find that unbearable to think about for long, and I think the performer should too. That discomfort is what I am scoring. A conventional part would have given the player pitches and dynamics and let them stay safely outside his body. This one puts his numbers in their lungs.

The stations and the six tiles

At 03:47 he talked in his sleep. The technician was not required to transcribe it, because it was not clinically relevant, and she transcribed it anyway. Page four is that transcript, set as large as I could set it: Harvey. Minot. Glasgow, not the Scottish one. Havre. Then a dispatcher’s order, clear the board, clear the board, the 6:10 is on the main. Shelby. And last, a sentence that is not a station: Mother, it’s only the wind in the wire.

Above the words runs the microphone trace, his voice in bursts and, under it, the watch, still ticking between the syllables. Down the right margin stand six dark tiles, each holding a white sign of my own making. They are not translations of the words. They stand beside the words the way a signal stands beside a track: a thing you read at speed that tells you whether to go.

This is the page where I stop pretending notation and language are separate systems. A list of station names is already a melody. It has a direction, east to west. It has intervals, the miles between. It has a meter, the rhythm of a timetable. It has a cadence, since every line on a railroad ends somewhere. The man was reciting his working life in the only order it ever had, and the flutist is asked to play the distance between the names.

Ending in an obituary

The last page has no notes and no signal traces. It is a newspaper obituary, set in a column so narrow and so long that it reads like a timetable, with a rail line and its ties running the full length of the left edge and every section marked as a stop. DIED. BORN. WORKED. WAGES. PRECEDED IN DEATH BY, which includes his wife and the 6:10 eastbound, discontinued in 1971. SURVIVED BY, which includes the watch.

In the middle of it, the column breaks into scattered words: the hum of the wire, a man who listened for a living and was paid by the hour. Then his daughter speaks, in one long sentence, about hearing the watch on the recording the clinic mailed her and realizing that someone had sat in a dark room with her father all night and written it down.

That sentence is the piece explaining itself, and it is the only explanation I am willing to give. A sleep study is a score someone else wrote about you while you were unconscious. An obituary is a score someone else writes about you once you are gone for good. Most of us will be written into both. Neither asks our permission, and both are composed in the strict, flat language of forms. I wanted a work for alto flute that admits music happens inside those documents, in the margins and the empty boxes, and that the performer’s job is to sound what the forms could not hold.

The objection

I know what some readers will say, because I have said it to myself. This is a medical record with a few clusters of notes laid under it. It is not a flute piece. And it borrows the paperwork of illness and death to make art, which is a cheap trick at best and a cruel one at worst.

On the first charge: I would ask anyone who believes that to sit with page three for the full thirty seconds, following the airflow line with a finger, and then tell me nothing musical happened. The structure is there. The timing is exact to the half second. What is missing is only the convention that says a thing becomes music when someone draws it on five lines.

On the second: Halvard Knudsen is invented. His wages, his stations, his daughter in Tacoma, the 6:10, all of it. The forms are real. I have filled them out, and so have you, and somebody has signed or failed to sign them about people we love. If music is not allowed in those rooms, then it has agreed to be absent from the places where most of our lives are actually recorded.

The technician did not filter out the watch. Neither did I.

Sketch Book Composition 809(*4)


 

Friday, November 20, 2026

The Text Before the Sound: Literary Pre-Performance Conditioning and the Notation of Interiority

The Text Before the Sound: Literary Pre-Performance Conditioning and the Notation of Interiority

Bil Smith, Composer Sound Morphology


There is a moment I have come to think of as the threshold. It happens perhaps twenty minutes before a performer walks onstage, or sits down at their instrument in a studio, or takes position in an ensemble. They are reading. Not a score. Not performance notes. Not my instructions about dynamics or articulation or the particular quality of attack I want on a given passage. They are reading a catalog essay, or a weather log, or an aphorism collection, or a short story. They are reading literature. And when they put it down and pick up their instrument, something has changed in the interior of the performance before a single sound has been made.


I call this practice Literary Pre-Performance Conditioning, or more simply, textual imprinting. I think it raises questions about the nature of musical notation that I find genuinely unresolved. Which is the best kind of question.


Where This Began

I did not arrive at this practice through theory. I arrived at it through frustration.

The question that started shifting things for me was this: what actually produces a particular quality of presence in a performer? Not a particular quality of action, but presence. The kind of thing that makes an audience lean forward without quite knowing why, before a note is sounded. The kind of thing that makes a passage feel inhabited rather than executed.

The answer I kept returning to was: the performer's interior state immediately before the performance. And interior states are not produced by instructions. They are produced by experience.


What I Give Performers to Read


The literary work I assign varies considerably by piece and by performer, but it falls into roughly six forms, each of which produces a different quality of conditioning.

The Catalog Essay is perhaps the most formally disruptive choice. The performer reads what appears to be curatorial writing about an exhibition, but the exhibition is, by degrees, revealed to be something else: the self, the body, the act of performing itself. The catalog essay produces in the performer a particular double consciousness, a sense of being simultaneously the observer and the observed, that I find extraordinarily useful for works in which the performer is asked to hold awareness of the act of performance alongside the performance itself.

The Weather Log is the form I use most frequently. There is something in the sustained attention of observational record-keeping, the daily noticing, the specificity of the instrument readings, the gap between what the instruments record and what the morning actually was, that produces in performers a quality I can only describe as calibrated openness. They arrive at the instrument already in a state of attending closely to what is, rather than anticipating what should be. For music that depends on the performer's real-time sensitivity to acoustical phenomena, room resonance, the behaviour of the instrument on a particular day, the way an ensemble listens to itself, this calibration is everything.

The Aphorism Collection works differently. Where the weather log builds attention through accumulation, the aphorism concentrates it through compression. A well-made aphorism produces a specific cognitive state: the mind arrives at the end of a sentence and finds it has been changed by the sentence, and it must hold both the before and the after simultaneously. Performers who have spent twenty minutes in that state bring a particular quality of held tension to the music. They are primed for the kind of meaning that arrives in a small gesture.


The Short Story gives the performer something more like a world. I tend to use short stories for ensemble work, where I want performers to share an imaginative space without sharing identical instructions. The story becomes the room they are all inside; the music becomes what that room sounds like.

Poetry, including work inspired by Ginsberg's long catalogs, Plath's clinical precision, Pindar's ode structure, produces in performers an acute sensitivity to the breath unit as a formal element. This has direct consequences for phrasing, for the shape of a line, for the relationship between gesture and silence.

The Essay-Poem Hybrid, which some of my textual works are, produces the most unpredictable conditioning, which is sometimes exactly what I want. A text that cannot be categorised, that is literature and philosophy and notation simultaneously, puts the performer in a state of productive uncertainty that I find generative for music that is itself formally uncategorizable.



The Philosophical Stakes

I want to be honest about how seriously I take what is happening here, philosophically, because I think it is easy to misread this practice as a species of programme music. As though I am asking performers to feel a particular emotion and then express it. That is not what I am doing.

What I am doing is closer to what the phenomenologist Maurice Merleau-Ponty described as the body schema: the way the body maintains a pre-reflective awareness of its own orientation, its own preparedness, its own readiness to act in specific ways. When a performer reads a weather log immediately before performing, I am not asking them to think about weather or observation or the gap between measurement and reality. I am asking them to inhabit a particular quality of attention, and the text is the vehicle for that inhabitation. The text works below the level of conscious interpretation. This is its whole purpose.

This distinction matters enormously. The performer is not told what to feel. They are conditioned into a mode of perceiving, and then they perform from inside that mode. The difference between these two things is the difference between acting and being.

There is also something important here about the irreversibility of the reading. Once a performer has read a piece of literature, they cannot un-read it. It has altered their interior landscape in a way that is not under their conscious control. This irreversibility is part of what makes the practice different from conventional performance notes, which a performer can follow or not follow, interpret or reinterpret, hold at arm's length as instructions. The literary text does not offer that arm's length. It enters the performer. And the performance that follows is, in a very precise sense, already begun before the instrument is raised.



What This Means for Notation

Here is where I think the deepest implications of this practice lie, and where I am most willing to claim that something genuinely new is being proposed.

Western art music notation is, at its foundation, a system for communicating what to do: pitch, duration, dynamics, articulation, sometimes affect (dolce, agitato, con brio), sometimes texture and approach. Even the most extended notations, from Ferneyhough to Lachenmann to Cage, are fundamentally systems of instruction, however complex, however open-ended, however philosophically elaborate. They address the performer as an executor of tasks, even when the tasks are tasks of interpretation or of choice.

What I am proposing, and what literary pre-performance conditioning enacts, is that there is a domain of musical performance that cannot be reached by instruction at all: the domain of the performer's interior state in the act of performance. And that this domain is not marginal or decorative. It is the domain in which the difference between a technically correct performance and a truly alive one is located.





This is not a romantic claim about inspiration or artistic ineffability. It is a structural observation. The performer's interior state shapes the infinitesimal decisions, the micro-timing, the sub-notational quality of attack and release, the quality of listening within an ensemble, the permeability to the acoustic event, that are not reachable by score. And these infinitesimal decisions are, in aggregate, what we hear when we hear music that is alive.

Conventional notation assumes that these micro-decisions are either unknowable, and therefore left to the performer's discretion, or irrelevant, and therefore not addressed. I want to argue that they are neither. They are conditionable. Not through instruction but through the carefully chosen textual experience that precedes the performance.


This means that the literary work I give a performer to read is, in a real and philosophical sense, part of the score. Not a supplement to it. Not a programme note. Not inspiration material. Part of the score. A notation of interiority.

This is, I think, a genuine expansion of what musical notation can mean. Not a rejection of the existing notation system but an acknowledgment of its constitutive limit, and a proposal for what lies on the other side of that limit.


Conditioning, Autonomy, and the Ethics of the Practice

I want to address a concern that this practice sometimes raises, because I take it seriously: does literary pre-performance conditioning compromise the performer's interpretive autonomy? Am I, in effect, manipulating the performer's interior state without their full awareness?

My answer is that this concern, while understandable, rests on a misreading of what autonomy means in performance. Every performance is already shaped by conditions the performer did not choose: the acoustics of the room, the instrument's particular character on a given day, what they ate, whether they slept, what they said to a colleague in the corridor ten minutes ago. The question is never whether the performer's state will be conditioned, because it always will be. The question is whether that conditioning is random or intentional, chaotic or considered.

What I am proposing is that the conditioning be chosen. Chosen by the composer, yes, but also chosen by the performer who agrees to the practice. Every performer I work with knows exactly what I am asking of them and why. The literary text is not a hidden apparatus. It is shared openly. The performer is a willing participant in their own conditioning, which transforms the act from manipulation into collaboration.

There is also something important about the specificity of the texts I choose. I am not trying to produce a generalized emotional state. I am trying to produce a specific quality of attention, a specific orientation of the performer's consciousness toward the act of performing. And this quality of attention is, in my experience, one that skilled performers recognise as valuable and want to cultivate. They are not being diminished by the practice. They are being offered a new kind of preparation.


The Texts as Objects in Themselves

I do not select existing literature for this practice, with rare exceptions. I write the texts specifically for the pieces they accompany. This is important. A catalog essay that I write as a conditioning text for a specific work is not merely a text about something. It is a text whose formal properties, whose sonic and rhythmic qualities, whose philosophical argument, are all calibrated to produce a specific quality of interior state in the performer who reads it.

The texts I have written draw on a wide range of literary traditions: the encyclopaedic witness mode of Vollmann, the ode's compressed fire in Pindar, the Beckettian imperative that cannot be refused, the long Ginsberg breath, the Plath clinical precision that discovers terror in the domestic, the Calvino invisible city that is also an argument about structure. These are not decorative influences. They are formal resources. The particular quality of attention that each tradition produces in a careful reader is the raw material of the conditioning.

This means that the composition of the literary text is not separate from the composition of the music. It is continuous with it. The score, the literary conditioning text, and the performance exist as a single complex work, distributed across different media, different temporal positions, different kinds of reading, but unified by the single question: what does it mean for a human being to be fully present in the act of making sound?

I do not have a complete answer to that question. I have a practice that keeps reopening it. That is, at this stage of my work, enough.


A Note on Documentation and Future Practice

I am aware that what I am describing raises immediate practical questions for documentation, pedagogy, and the historical record. If the literary text is part of the score, how is it archived? How is a future performer given access to the full work? How does a musicologist analyse a piece whose notation exists in two radically different media?

These are questions I am actively working through. My current practice is to publish the literary text and the musical score as a single document, what I am beginning to call a composite score, with guidance on the pre-performance reading practice included as an integral section of the score rather than as supplementary material.

This is not a fully resolved solution. The temporal relationship between the reading and the performance, how long before, how many times, remains deliberately somewhat open. Different performers in different contexts will find their own relationship to the text, and that variability is not a flaw in the system. It is part of the system. The conditioning is not a mechanism for producing identical performances. It is a mechanism for producing performances that are each, in their own way, fully inhabited.

The score tells the performer what to do. The text conditions who is doing it. Both are necessary. Neither is sufficient alone. Together they reach toward something that I believe has always been at the heart of performance, the complete presence of a human being in an act of making, and that notation has, until now, not quite been able to name.


Toward a Quantum Polyphony: Symbolic Metaphors and Deep Science in the Scores of Bil Smith by Thomas Hull

 


In the radically entangled notational landscapes of Bil Smith, we encounter not scores as linear documents, but speculative surfaces which are part cartographic event, part para-chemical ritual. These are not mere directions for sonic action. They are entangled fields in which temporality, neurobiology, linguistics, and post-mathematical logics converge in sedimentary strata of signification. Each score is less an instruction than a biosemantic artifact: a zone where cognition and biology co-compose.


What emerges, through careful looking, is a metabolization of deep science through symbolic intuition. The works on bilsmith.com do not depict a world. They perform it. The notation becomes a form of speculative modeling, where aesthetic structure draws from biochemical scaffolding, from informatic grammars, from entropic behaviors embedded within matter.



These scores conjure an epistemological liminality: we are always on the threshold of comprehension, of musical fluency, yet never fully permitted entry. Glyphs mutate mid-sentence. Standard staves dissolve into pharmacological spirals. Whole pharmaceutical registers and non-place names like “Equitroclage,” “Axirol,” or “Penopolclip” become both agents and actors within the notation, suggesting a pharmakon of sound: a cure and a toxin, a formula and a hallucination.



Materiality and the Post-Scriptural

Smith’s scores are artifacts of extreme mediation. They emerge not only from human intention but from algorithmic interventions, coded languages, and machinic generativity. There is a confrontation with the post-scriptural: language no longer denotes; it deforms. It swims. Musical notation here is not a universal system but an idiolect emerging as a personalized script for an ever-mutating sonic organism. And within that script, deep metaphors reside: anatomical fragments, botanical morphologies, even synthetic hormonal flows render the score less a composition than a hormonal map of vibration.

The symbolic logic here is recombinant. In one score, a metonymic loop forms between a cochlear cross-section and a segment of urban topology. In another, a waveform is diagrammed like a viral bloom suggesting that sound is not produced, but incubated. These references to microbiology, gene therapy, and cognitive science suggest a deeply embedded logic.  They become a pre-conscious system through which music becomes a form of evolutionary utterance.



Temporal Entanglements

The scores insist on time not as duration, but as density. There is a saturation of graphic matter that refuses horizontal temporality. Instead, time thickens, folds, and burrows. One feels that the event of the score happens all at once, like a complex protein folding in on itself (a sonic autopoiesis?). The performer is not just an interpreter but a biosensor, activating latent structures, decoding embedded ontologies.

What then is a musical gesture in this context? It is a data transfer. An epigenetic trigger. A moment in which sound extends beyond the ear, entering the bloodstream, altering our perceptual metabolics. Smith’s metaphors are not decorative. They are functional code working upon the performer, the viewer, and the reader at a cellular level.

Toward a Science of Affect

There is a great ambition here: to fuse the felt and the formulated. To allow the experiential ambiguity of metaphor to co-exist with the precision of molecular reasoning. Sound is chemical. Listening is molecular. Composition is a prosthesis for interspecies communication, for post-human poetics.

We might say these scores operate as heuristic prosthetics: tools not for the reproduction of sound but for the invention of new cognitive topologies. In this sense, Smith is not composing music, but composing models for neuro-affective activation. These are not scores for concerts, but protocols for experience.

And this is where his work opens onto a broader horizon. Beyond genre, beyond media, even beyond music itself, Bil Smith proposes notation as a speculative practice: a way of thinking, of becoming-with the unknown. A lexicon of the future embedded in the language of the now.

-Thomas Hull for The Guardian

"Dimidius" for Solo Piano




"Dimidius"

For Piano

Bil Smith Composer

Commissioned by Scapa Group PLC

Utilizing an encapsulated tranche system, the notation for "Dimidius" segments motifs through the strategic implementation of bounding boxes. This approach elucidates the nuanced interplay of shifting coalitions of forms as they manifest in the performer's interpretations across temporal shifts.


Through a series of concepts, graphic protocols, and notations, "Dimidius" serves as a visual framework, delineating distinct motifs and shifting coalitions of forms and their perceptual manifestations over time. The use of bounding boxes as a notational device underscores the fluidity of perception and the multifaceted nature of artistic expression, highlighting the inherent dynamism of the compositional process.



Monday, November 16, 2026

It’s an itinerary disguised as a score. Pack light.


Along the staff, the “notes” are moiré discs, spinning fields of fine lines that pulse like sonar. Above them, accidentals drift loose from any note at all: triple flats, sharps with arrows, a flat with a tiny 3, signs that bend pitch with nothing left to bend. They hang there like a star chart.

And then the place names rise, each one taller than the last: Kotzebue, Thedford, Shkodër, Honiara, Funafuti, Nuku’alofa, Tamanrasset. Remote towns on the edges of maps, typed with the deadpan confidence of an Ed Ruscha word painting. They work as a crescendo you read rather than hear: the further the place, the louder the type.

Chance runs through all of it. A pair of painted dice sits in the corner, and an ace of spades lies tilted across the staff. Where you go, and what you hear when you get there, is partly a roll of the dice.

It’s an itinerary disguised as a score. Pack light.




 

WIP. Nothing Stays in its Lane


On this page, nothing stays in its lane.

Down the left edge, the only “conventional” music on the page: a column of treble clefs, each with a single flat, and noteheads swapped for pairs of chrome ball bearings. It reads like an abacus more than a melody, notation reduced to counting.

Then everything else floods in. A hot-pink figure, built from melting, inflated letterforms, staggers across the page like a word that forgot how to spell itself. A blue-and-white porcelain beast carries a gilded casket, with a blue chimp perched on top, curiosities from a collector’s shelf. A carnival-coloured column rises on the right like a broken carousel. Big yellow and black letters crash into each other above the phrase SANS WITHOUT, “without” said twice in two languages, a redundancy that cancels itself out.

Beneath it all: a green radial glow, checkerboard ripples, a rusted runway, and perforated halftone panels marching off the edge in perspective.

Is it a score? It’s a cabinet of curiosities that happens to have clefs in it. The performer’s job isn’t to decode it. It’s to decide what’s worth sounding out of all this excess, and what is just sans, without.


 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Notation Should Frighten You a Little. On the productive terror of the page


 
Notation Should Frighten You a Little

On the productive terror of the page

Most musicians remember the first score that scared them.

You open the folder and something is wrong. The page is too dark, or too empty. The rhythms are nested so deep you can't see the bottom. There's a symbol you've never seen, and no key to explain it. Your stomach drops a little. Your first thought is: I can't do this.

I want to make a case for that feeling. Not as an accident, and not as a failure of the composer to communicate. As the point.

Notation should frighten you a little. If it doesn't, I'm not sure it's doing its job.



The comfortable page

Standard notation is a marvelous invention, and I mean that. Five lines, a clef, a key, a meter. In a few seconds a trained musician knows where they are, how fast to go, roughly what the piece will feel like. It's one of the great user interfaces in human history.

But a great interface is designed to reassure you. It promises that nothing on the page will surprise you too much. Everything is where you expect it. You can sight-read it, rehearse it twice, and play it on Saturday.

That's wonderful for a lot of music. It's poison for some. Comfort makes us efficient, and efficiency makes us skim. We stop reading the page and start recognising it. The eyes slide over familiar shapes and the hands do what they've always done. The music gets played. Nobody is actually there.

I don't want my performers to recognise my scores. I want them to meet them.


What fear does to attention

Fear is the most honest form of attention we have. When something frightens you, you can't skim it. Your pulse picks up, your eyes slow down, every detail matters. You read the page the way you'd read a contract you were about to sign with your own blood.

Kafka put it better than I can, in a letter he wrote as a young man:

"A book must be the axe for the frozen sea within us."

I think the same is true of a score. It shouldn't slide into the hands like a warm glove. It should crack something. It should put the performer in a state where habit doesn't work any more and they have to think, with their whole body, about every mark.

Rilke, opening his Duino Elegies, called beauty "nothing but the beginning of terror." I've always found that comforting, oddly. It tells me that the shiver I feel in front of a difficult page isn't the opposite of beauty. It's the doorway into it.



The fear I mean, and the fear I don't

I should be careful here, because there's a bad version of this argument, and I've watched composers live inside it.

I don't mean the fear of humiliation. A score that exists to make players look foolish, or to show off how clever the composer is, isn't frightening. It's just unkind. Performers can smell contempt on a page, and they're right to resent it.

The fear I mean is closer to vertigo. It's the feeling at the top of a high diving board. You know you can do it. You also know you might not do it perfectly, and that the attempt will cost you something. You climb anyway, because the view from up there is worth it.

That kind of fear comes from respect, not contempt. When I write something that asks more than seems possible, I'm saying I believe the player can go further than the standard page has ever asked them to. The difficulty is a compliment. It just doesn't always feel like one in the first rehearsal.




How I build it in

Over the years I've found my own ways of putting a little fear onto the page.

Too much. Some of my pages are deliberately overloaded: rhythms nested inside rhythms, beams stacked like girders, more instructions than any one person can follow. The player has to choose what to let go of, and every choice is exposed.

Too little. Other pages are almost empty. A single mark in a field of white can be more terrifying than a thousand notes, because there's nowhere to hide.

The wrong vocabulary. I've written scores that read like toxicology reports, pharmaceutical warnings and credit ratings. When a page talks about dosage, contraindications or default risk, the performer can't fall back on musical habit. The language itself is unfamiliar ground.

Instability. In my moiré scores, the slightest shift in how you read the page changes what appears on it. In my opera pages, the text turns at every corner until you're reading upside down. The ground keeps moving, so you can't stand on it the way you used to.

Someone watching. Red audit marks, silhouettes in the margins, a box with nothing in it. I like a page to feel observed. A performer who feels watched plays as if every sound counts, which it does.

None of these is a trick. Each is a way of switching off autopilot and switching on the person.

A little, not a lot

Notice the title says a little. I don't want anyone paralysed. Too much fear and the hands freeze, the mind shuts down, and nothing good comes out. What I'm after is the edge: just enough fear to wake you up, not so much that you run.

John Cage was once asked about people's resistance to new ideas. He said he didn't understand why anyone was frightened of them, adding: "I'm frightened of the old ones." I've carried that line around for years. The comfortable page is the old idea. It's the one that should worry us, because it lets us play without listening, read without seeing, and perform without being present at all.

So the next time you open a score and your stomach drops, don't close it. Stay with that feeling a moment longer. It's not telling you to stop. It's telling you you've finally found something worth playing.

Rethinking the Opera Score, Part 2. Where the libretto went

Rethinking the Opera Score, Part 2

Where the libretto went

(Link to part 1 below)

In Part 1, I said the libretto had dissolved into the score. I'd like to take that back, or at least half of it.

When I laid these pages out side by side, what struck me was how much language there is on them. Long lines of capital letters run around the edges of the sheet. Sentences hit a corner and turn, then turn again, until they're upside down. Seventeen little squares each have a sentence wrapped around them like tape around a parcel. Some passages coil into rings around a silver disc. There are more words here than in plenty of real librettos.

So the libretto didn't disappear. It moved. It stopped being the thing anyone sings, and became the ground everything else stands on. I've started thinking of it as terrain.



Reading in circles

The story pages are built as rectangular spirals. A sentence starts at the top left and runs across. When it reaches the corner, it doesn't drop to a new line the way text usually does. It turns and heads down the right side. At the bottom it turns again and runs back toward the left, upside down. Then up the left edge, and around again, a little smaller each time.

I let the words break wherever the corners fall. "GIR" finishes one line and "LHOOD" starts the next, heading downward. I like that small violence. Every corner is a hinge, and every hinge makes you stop and work a little harder.

What I wanted was for reading itself to become physical. You can't follow these sentences sitting still. You turn the page, or your head, or your whole body. By the time a performer has read one page, they've already danced it.

The music sits in the middle, inside all that circling text: clusters of notes, heavy beams, accidentals with little arrows, a dotted cloud, a pale triangle. The story surrounds it like a ring road around an old city. The only way in is the long way round.






Seventeen footnotes that do something

The little numbers scattered through the story lead somewhere: a grid of seventeen squares, one for each footnote.

Each square works the same way. A sentence wraps around all four sides, turning as it goes, so it finishes upside down. In the middle is a tiny piece of notation: a few notes, a sharp with an arrow, an invented sign, sometimes a little drawing that could be a seed, a shell or a lightbulb.

I wrote the sentences like footnotes in a scholarly edition, if the scholar had been up all night:

  • "Antarctica as nation-state? Theory exists. See Cartographies of Ice (unpublished)."
  • "'Semi-lexemic' = almost language. Smoke that conjugates verbs in an undocumented dialect of ash."
  • "Forecast: existential dread, 70% chance of narrative collapse."
  • "Estimated to be pronounced 'GH'RRT'."

I've always loved the critical apparatus at the back of a serious edition, all those notes standing politely outside the text and explaining it. I wanted mine to stop explaining and start doing. When a performer reaches footnote 14 in the story, square 14 switches on. The sentence around its edge sets the mood (a 70% chance of collapse, in that case) and the notation in the middle is what you play under that forecast.


So the footnotes aren't commentary any more. They're the control panel.

The ruins of an opera house

I made two versions of the footnote page. In one, the squares just float on white. In the other, I framed them: three red stripes down each side, two red bars along the bottom, a huge hollow treble clef on the left and a bass clef facing it on the right.

A clef is the most practical sign in music. Without it, you can't read a single note. I liked the idea of throwing them out of the music altogether and standing them at the edges of the page like a pair of columns, with nothing left between them that they could actually govern.

The red stripes work the same way. To me they look like the frame of a stage, a proscenium. The opera house is still there, but only as an outline around the edge. It holds the work up. It just doesn't get to tell it what to do any more.

Orbits

Some of the text doesn't spiral in squares. It runs in rings around a silver disc that could be a lens, a turntable or a sundial. Little green bars break the rings here and there, like markers on a dial.

Those rings are where I put time, and time misbehaves in them. There's a carousel of skeletal birds turning in a glass dome, naming "events that had never occurred." There are kiosks shown "as they would appear ten minutes into the future." There's a sun that never sets and casts no shadow, "yet the plaza slowly darkened."

There's also a caretaker keeping a green ledger of all these anomalies, with a diagram of octagonal holes beside every entry. I'll admit that's me. A notebook full of strange events, each with an odd little diagram, is more or less a description of what I've been making for years.

In Part 1, I said time in this piece is collaged rather than measured. The rings take it somewhere else. If you follow one all the way round, you end up back where you started, just one ring further in. In one version there's a small bronze shape at the centre, holding a single black-and-silver sign. I like to think the whole story keeps circling that one mark and never quite gets there.





A world, not a plot

If you read the spirals from start to finish, you get something like a story, though I'd hesitate to call it one. In a frozen hemisphere "not yet ratified by any known parliament," three girls, Jorie, Esme and Lint, come out each solstice from an ice palace. A chrome-rimmed SUV rolls across the sea ice with nobody at the wheel. The chimneys start talking in half-words made of carbon dioxide. Pirates turn up in matching hoodies stitched with the logo of a start-up that has somehow become conscious, rowing kayaks covered in old barcodes. The ice cracks. The car rises out of the crack. Somewhere, a forgotten goddess of forced-air heating can still be heard.

Nothing builds. Nothing gets resolved. Nobody learns anything. That's deliberate. I'm not interested in plot here. I'm interested in building a world: piling up places, objects and rumours, each described with the fussy precision of a mail-order catalogue and the logic of a bad dream.

Right in the middle of one page there's a red box with a made-up word, "Obbotti," in fat white letters, with a little photograph cut into them. I put it there the way a billboard turns up on a country road. It's the commercial world barging into the landscape uninvited, as it always does.

None of this is meant to be followed like a narrative. It's meant to set the weather. When a performer reads that the ice has cracked "not metaphorically," I'm not telling them what happens next. I'm telling them how cold the next passage is.

What I'm asking of performers

If the libretto is terrain, the performer is the one walking across it. Here's roughly how I picture that walk.

You travel. You follow the text around the spiral or the ring. The route is set; the pace isn't. However long it takes you to get round a page, that's how long that section lasts. Your reading is the clock.

You switch things on. Each footnote number you pass calls up its square. The sentence around the edge tells you the conditions, and the notation in the middle is what you do under them.

You turn. The text turns, so you turn with it. Every corner is a small physical event, and I'd love for the upside-down lines at the bottom of a page to sound different from the upright ones at the top.

You almost speak. In Part 1 I said nobody sings words in this piece, and I stand by that. But one footnote defines "semi-lexemic" as "almost language," and another guesses at how a word might be pronounced. If words come out of you at all, I want them in that halfway state: shaped like language, without quite arriving.

There's no single right way through. There are a lot of possible routes, and the shape of the page keeps every one of them honest.

Living inside it

I ended Part 1 by saying this opera isn't staged, it's activated. I've changed my mind about that too.

"Activated" still sounds like a machine waiting for someone to flip the switch. What I see on these pages is more like a place you live in. The text makes the walls and the roads. The footnotes are the control room. The clefs and red stripes are what's left of the opera house. The rings are a sky where time loops and the sun won't go down. You don't switch this world on. You move through it, and the moving is the music.

Opera has always been a world made of words and music. All I've done is take that literally, and build the world on the page.


LINK to Part One:

https://soundmorphology.blogspot.com/2025/06/rethinking-opera-score.html