Four, Twice
Some notes on Clarionista
By Bil Smith
The melody in Clarionista is the plainest thing I've put on paper in a long time, and I feel oddly defensive about it. Treble clef, one flat, 4/4, a repeat at each end, a whole rest. It rises, peaks, and comes down again. Sit at a piano with it and you'd have it in a minute.
My scores usually go the other way. I once wrote that notation should frighten you a little, and I still believe it. This page doesn't frighten anybody if all you read is the notes. So whatever it costs the player has moved out to the edges, into a set of numbers that I want to go through one at a time. I don't think they get looked at closely on a first pass. I'm including myself in that.
Start at the top. There are rows of six-digit counters, zero-padded the way a numbering stamp or a till roll prints them, and each row has a date in front of it: 14.03.78, 15.03.78, 16.03.78, 17.03.78. Day, month, year, the European order.
On the first day the count goes 000001, 000002, 000003, 000004, 000004, and on up to 000010. The four is printed twice. The second day does the same thing once, at 000013, and finishes on 000020. If you were the person reconciling this you'd circle the doubles and keep going. One slip a day isn't much.
The third day is where I'd stop and put the pen down. 000022 appears twice and 000023 doesn't appear at all. 25 is doubled. 000036 sits between 000026 and 000027, nowhere near where it belongs. The fourth day begins at 000031, drops back to 000022 and 000023, which are yesterday's numbers, doubles 35, doubles 36, and climbs to 000040. Underneath, 17.03.78 is stamped a second time with a single 000031 after it, and nothing more.
I go back and forth on that second 17.03.78. Some days it reads like a fresh start that didn't take. Other days it looks like somebody hit the date stamp twice and walked off. I can't settle it, and I've stopped trying.
Then there's the SUMME row (German for total): 000020, 000040, an empty cell, 000060, 000080, 000100. Clean twenties. Whoever wrote them wasn't looking at the entries above, or was and didn't care. The empty box in the middle is the one place where a number just wasn't supplied, and I trust it more than anything else in the ledger.
Running up the right margin, turned on its side, are three sums. Work them yourself if you like. I'd rather you didn't take my word for it.
16 + 17 + 18 + 29 + 29 − 219 + 24 + 20 is written as 90. It comes to −66.
At 11.20: 21 + 27 + 23 + 28 − 24 + 25 + 20 is written as 115. It comes to 120.
At 11.40: 26 + 27 + 28 + 23 + 29 − 28 + 39 + 30 is written as 140. It comes to 174.
The −219 bothers me most. Everything around it is a small two-digit number, then this, and the total doesn't register it at all. The other two sums are off by less, but look at what they claim: 90, 115, 140, each one twenty-five more than the last. With 11.20 and 11.40 written above them like times on a clock, it's hard for me not to see someone checking a figure through a morning and writing down the figure that was expected of them.
(Anyone know Hanne Darboven?)
That's my reading. The page doesn't say who did it or why. But an error that keeps landing on a neat schedule doesn't behave like an accident, and I haven't found another way to read it.
The fractions over the notes are all sixteenths: 17/16, 19/16, 23/16, 25/16, 29/16, 29/16, 23/16, 37/16, 31/16, 37/16, 41/16, 43/16. Anyone who works with the overtone series will read them as partials over a low fundamental, with 16 as home. 17/16 is about 105 cents up. 23/16 is around 628, which no keyboard will give you. 43/16 is past the octave, close to 1712. The ±1/4 arrows on the noteheads are the practical side of it, how far to bend each written pitch toward its partial.
Look at the numerators by themselves for a second. 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43. That's every prime from 17 to 43, with none skipped, plus a 25. The 25 is the only number in the list that isn't prime, and it sits fourth, which sends me straight back to the ledger, where four is the first number printed twice. I'm not going to tell you that was planned. I'm telling you what I see when I look.
(At this point, if you don't know Hanne Darboven, stop reading this)
25/16 has something else in it. It's 5/4 times 5/4, two pure major thirds stacked. Hold on to that for the top of the arc.
Over the whole melody there's a long curve, drawn in several strokes, from 19/16 to 43/16. At its highest point is a column of +1/4 markings, nine of them, with a single −1/4 on top. Nine quarter tones up is about 450 cents. One back down leaves 400, which is an equal-tempered major third. So the phrase spends its whole length on primes and odd partials and arrives, at the peak, at the most ordinary interval there is, in its tempered form, about fourteen cents wide of the pure 5/4 tucked inside that 25.
The lone −1/4 is the mark I keep coming back to. Nine instructions to go higher, then one small step back at the very top. To me it looks like someone correcting an overstatement by the least amount that will pass. The ledger hides its corrections. The arc writes every one of them out, where the player has no choice but to read them.
There are a few things on the left side I can't account for very well. A gray rectangle, worn and scratched, something like an old stamp pad or a patch of paper that's been erased too often. Bits of ruled line near it, corners and short verticals, which might be the beginning of a drawing of a building. Wavy lines between the ledger rows, the kind you'd use to strike out an empty space.
I don't know what happened between the 14th and the 17th of March 1978, and the score doesn't say. It's easy to imagine a ticket office, or a goods yard, or a hospital desk at night, and every time I do it I notice I'm filling in a story the paper never offered. Readers will do the same, and they're welcome to. I'd only ask that nobody mistake the story for information.
The piece is dated Thanksgiving week, 2026, forty-eight years after the ledger. I know what that holiday asks people to do, which is sit down and count what they have. I'm leaving that alone.
There's no instruction to the player about any of the numbers. You can play the tune and let the margins sit there. Or you can let them get under your skin, so that every bent pitch feels like adjusting a figure. My guess is that most performances will land somewhere in between, and not in the same place twice. I'd like to hear both kinds.

No comments:
Post a Comment