Thirty Seconds Without Air
Selepiton for Alto Flute, a sleep study and an obituary
By Bil Smith
Link to PDF
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1AtWZTlCATZIbNMAp1f2RsvvQZr_Z8dfR/view?usp=sharing
The first number in this score is 34.2. Per hour.
That is an apnea-hypopnea index, the count of times an hour a sleeping body stops breathing or nearly stops. It sits in a box on page one, in clinic type, next to a sleep efficiency of 71% and a lowest blood oxygen of 79%. Below the boxes, a sleep technician describes an old man who arrived on foot with his own pillow and a railroad watch he would not take off. Below her note, the notation begins.
I have spent years arguing that a score can be a crime scene, a pharmacy label, a credit rating, a weather log. This one is a medical chart, and then it is a death notice. I want to explain why I think that is the most honest place a piece of music has ever started.
What is on the pages
Five pages, and none of them looks like a flute part.
Page one is the summary of findings. Page two is a hypnogram, the staircase graph a sleep lab draws of one night, stage by stage, 808 thirty-second steps from lights out at 22:47 to lights on at 05:31, with nine numbered events the technician wrote up in the margins. Page three is a single epoch at 02:40: eight channels of raw signal, brain and eyes and chin and airflow, chest, oxygen, heart, and a microphone. Page four is the man talking in his sleep. Page five is his obituary, printed as one long narrow strip with a railroad track running down its edge.
The notation enters on the first two pages, underneath the clinical material, the way a second sleeper lies under the covers. Dense clusters of noteheads, microtonal accidentals with arrows, beams stacked like ties on a siding, a small curl of cloud, circled numbers. It is not attached to anything in the report. It sits below it, in the white space a clinic leaves for a signature that never arrives.
The page with no notes
Page three has no notation on it at all. I left it that way on purpose, and it is the page performers ask me about first.
Look at the airflow channel. A sine wave, two breaths, then a flat line from six seconds to twenty-eight. Twenty-two seconds in which, as the technician writes, nothing passes in or out of him. Directly below it, the chest and abdomen keep heaving the whole time. The body is trying. The throat has closed.
That is a score. It has an exact duration and a contradiction built into it that no articulation mark of mine could improve on: two lines that should move together, one working and one stopped. Above them, the EEG gives one second of spindle, which the technician compares to a pencil tapped twice on a desk. Below them, the microphone shows thirty small spikes in thirty seconds. That is the watch. It never misses.
I am asking the flutist to read this page the way a clinician reads it, slowly, one channel at a time, and then to play what they found. Some will play the flat line as silence. Some will play it as air with no tone, which is what it literally is. A third might hold one key down for twenty-two seconds without blowing and listen to the pad close. I have no objection to any of them. The page does not tell you what to do. It tells you what happened.
A breathing instrument for a man who stopped breathing
Why the alto flute? Because there is no instrument more honest about breath. A flutist cannot hide an inhale. Every phrase ends where the lungs end, and the alto, with its long tube and its slow, cool sound, makes the cost of air audible. You hear it run out.
So the piece asks a player whose whole craft is the management of breath to perform a night in which breath kept failing. Two hundred and eleven arousals. Each one is the body jerking itself back into air. The flutist has to decide, phrase by phrase, whether to breathe where he did not, or to stop where he stopped.
I find that unbearable to think about for long, and I think the performer should too. That discomfort is what I am scoring. A conventional part would have given the player pitches and dynamics and let them stay safely outside his body. This one puts his numbers in their lungs.
The stations and the six tiles
At 03:47 he talked in his sleep. The technician was not required to transcribe it, because it was not clinically relevant, and she transcribed it anyway. Page four is that transcript, set as large as I could set it: Harvey. Minot. Glasgow, not the Scottish one. Havre. Then a dispatcher’s order, clear the board, clear the board, the 6:10 is on the main. Shelby. And last, a sentence that is not a station: Mother, it’s only the wind in the wire.
Above the words runs the microphone trace, his voice in bursts and, under it, the watch, still ticking between the syllables. Down the right margin stand six dark tiles, each holding a white sign of my own making. They are not translations of the words. They stand beside the words the way a signal stands beside a track: a thing you read at speed that tells you whether to go.
This is the page where I stop pretending notation and language are separate systems. A list of station names is already a melody. It has a direction, east to west. It has intervals, the miles between. It has a meter, the rhythm of a timetable. It has a cadence, since every line on a railroad ends somewhere. The man was reciting his working life in the only order it ever had, and the flutist is asked to play the distance between the names.
Ending in an obituary
The last page has no notes and no signal traces. It is a newspaper obituary, set in a column so narrow and so long that it reads like a timetable, with a rail line and its ties running the full length of the left edge and every section marked as a stop. DIED. BORN. WORKED. WAGES. PRECEDED IN DEATH BY, which includes his wife and the 6:10 eastbound, discontinued in 1971. SURVIVED BY, which includes the watch.
In the middle of it, the column breaks into scattered words: the hum of the wire, a man who listened for a living and was paid by the hour. Then his daughter speaks, in one long sentence, about hearing the watch on the recording the clinic mailed her and realizing that someone had sat in a dark room with her father all night and written it down.
That sentence is the piece explaining itself, and it is the only explanation I am willing to give. A sleep study is a score someone else wrote about you while you were unconscious. An obituary is a score someone else writes about you once you are gone for good. Most of us will be written into both. Neither asks our permission, and both are composed in the strict, flat language of forms. I wanted a work for alto flute that admits music happens inside those documents, in the margins and the empty boxes, and that the performer’s job is to sound what the forms could not hold.
The objection
I know what some readers will say, because I have said it to myself. This is a medical record with a few clusters of notes laid under it. It is not a flute piece. And it borrows the paperwork of illness and death to make art, which is a cheap trick at best and a cruel one at worst.
On the first charge: I would ask anyone who believes that to sit with page three for the full thirty seconds, following the airflow line with a finger, and then tell me nothing musical happened. The structure is there. The timing is exact to the half second. What is missing is only the convention that says a thing becomes music when someone draws it on five lines.
On the second: Halvard Knudsen is invented. His wages, his stations, his daughter in Tacoma, the 6:10, all of it. The forms are real. I have filled them out, and so have you, and somebody has signed or failed to sign them about people we love. If music is not allowed in those rooms, then it has agreed to be absent from the places where most of our lives are actually recorded.
The technician did not filter out the watch. Neither did I.





No comments:
Post a Comment