Sunday, November 22, 2026

"Nobody Is Driving" On empty seats, full dashboards and the waiting score



"Nobody Is Driving"   

On empty seats, full dashboards and the waiting score 

By Bil Smith

There is a small fleet parked in my files and none of it has a license.

A lavender chassis carrying six fat capsules lashed down with blue webbing and plastic buckles, a glass observation deck on top with two yellow seats, three antennas ending in little balls like the stems of cocktail olives. An orange-and-navy roadster with a vintage grille, piled to the ceiling with pods, one of them skewered clean through on a steel rod. A pink submarine on pink tires with butterfly wings where the tail fins should be and a boarding ladder striped like a candy cane. A blue inflatable bladder with 04 stenciled on its side, wrapped in red cord, fed by a corrugated red hose. A sage-green delivery truck sitting very still on a white plinth


If you asked me what they are, the honest answer would be that I think they're scores, and that I'm still finding out what kind.

Anyone who has spent time with British architecture of the 1960s will see where they came from. Archigram drew buildings that refused to stay put. Ron Herron's Walking City of 1964 was a set of enormous insect-legged pods that would stroll across the planet to wherever they were needed. Peter Cook's Plug-In City, the same year, was a megastructure that never finished: a frame with living capsules craned in and out as tastes changed. Michael Webb's Cushicle was a whole dwelling you wore on your back and inflated when you got where you were going. Almost none of it was built. All of it was serious, and most of it was funny, and the group never seemed to feel any need to choose.

That last part is the part I took. A score is also a building that isn't built until someone shows up and stands in it. It might as well have wheels.

Start with the capsules, since there are more of them than anything else.




In Plug-In City the capsule was the unit of change. You didn't renovate, you unplugged a room and craned in another. Look at the lavender vehicle and you'll see the same arrangement: yellow, red, mint, violet and navy pods, each a different size, each held to the frame by a strap and a buckle and nothing more permanent than that. Any one of them could come off at a rest stop. The thing stays a vehicle either way.

That is roughly how I want a score's materials to sit: lashed on where you can see them, so the player can see where one module ends and the next begins and can wonder, reasonably, whether the buckle will hold at speed.

It's hard to say the word capsule in new-music company without someone thinking of Ferneyhough's Unity Capsule, the solo flute piece from the mid-seventies whose pages look as if a flock of starlings landed on the staff and then filed paperwork. The title has always struck me as a beautiful contradiction. A capsule is a sealed container. Unity is what you'd hope to find inside. What you actually find inside is a flautist doing about nine incompatible things at once while being asked, very politely, to make them cohere.

I should say this properly, in the dialect, so nobody thinks I've gone soft. Each capsule constitutes a locally autonomous parametric enclosure whose relation to the chassis is neither hierarchical nor contingent but tensile, mediated by the strap as a site of negotiated adherence, such that the global morphology of the vehicle is continuously re-inscribed by the potential detachment of any constituent pod. The buckle is the formal hinge of the work. It is the moment at which structural intention submits itself to the rumour of its own undoing.

In English: it's all held on with luggage straps, and that's the point.

Then the ladders. Every one of these vehicles has too many.

The lavender one has five or six thin yellow ladders, the kind that come on a sprue in a model kit, running from the running boards up to the capsules and from the capsules up to a railed deck. The orange roadster has white wire ladders and two catwalks hanging off its sides like balconies on a cruise ship that has been told it's a pickup truck. A couple of the ladders, if you trace them, don't arrive anywhere. They stop at the side of a pod with no hatch.

It took me an embarrassingly long time to see what these were. A ladder is a ledger line with rungs. Ledger lines are the short strokes we add above or below the staff when a pitch climbs out of the five lines it was given, and anyone who has read a piccolo part or a contrabassoon part knows how quickly they pile up, until you're counting rungs to find out which note you're standing on. The staff is the chassis. Ledger lines are how you climb off it.

Piranesi got there first, of course, with his imaginary prisons full of staircases that go up into fog and never come down, and Ferneyhough got there second with the Carceri d'Invenzione cycle, seven works named after those etchings, written through most of the eighties. I'm happy to come in third, with plastic.

Here's the dialect again, because I promised. The ladder operates as a vector of ascent whose terminus is structurally withheld; its rungs articulate a quantised trajectory through registral space while denying the arrival that quantisation implies. The performer is thereby positioned not at a destination but within an iterated approach, a condition of perpetual mounting, which is to say: practising.

Which, to be fair, is also what a ladder that goes nowhere is for.

Nobody is driving.

The orange-and-teal rover has a clear bubble cockpit, a steering column, a little chrome dashboard and one cream-colored seat, ribbed like a 1970s dentist's chair, with nobody in it. The lavender vehicle has two yellow seats up on its observation deck, also empty. There's a shape in the cab of the green truck that might be a figure or might be a reflection, and I've decided not to find out.

An empty seat in front of a set of controls is the most accurate picture of a score I know. The thing is fully equipped. The gauges are installed and the antennas are up. It's waiting for a body, and it has no opinion yet about whose. When the player climbs in, the vehicle stops being an object and becomes a duty.

The blue inflatable makes that literal in a way I still find a little alarming. It's a bladder, a big soft drum of blue plastic, and printed across its skin, faint as a watermark, are staff lines with notes on them. The notation is the hide of the thing. Underneath a stenciled 04 the staves curve around the belly and disappear. Red cord is netted over the whole body, the wheels are wrapped in red thread like a road map of veins, and a fat red corrugated hose runs from the body down to a cluster of pressure gauges near the ground.

I keep coming back to those gauges. Our word for a bar of music is a measure, and here is a cluster of actual measuring instruments bolted to a score, reading pressure. That's what a dynamic marking is, if you're honest about it: a request for a certain number of pounds per square inch, from lungs or bow arm or stick, delivered through a hose. Michael Webb's Suitaloon was a garment that inflated into a house. This is a score that inflates into a performance, or deflates into a puddle of blue vinyl, depending on who's on the pump.

In the dialect: the inflatable instantiates notation as epidermal condition rather than prescriptive overlay, collapsing the ontological distance between instruction and vessel; its pressurisation indexes the somatic labour of execution as a measurable, indeed metered, quantity, while the numeral 04 refuses to disclose whether it denominates sequence, catalogue, or merely a jersey.

I'm not going to tell you what the 04 means. Some instructions should arrive sealed.

Two of them don't fit the fleet, and they're the two I trust most.

The pink submarine is a submarine on wheels, which is already a category error, and then it goes further. It has a propeller on top, turned sideways like a desk fan. It has two butterfly wings where a sensible boat would have a rudder. Its portholes are rimmed and riveted and there's a periscope and a couple of plumbing elbows sticking out of the conning tower. The boarding ladder, red and white, is unmistakably a candy cane. Every part of it was designed for a different element. Water, air, road, a dentist's waiting room in 1962. It is equipped to go everywhere and therefore goes nowhere with total confidence.

I think a lot of the scores I admire are pink submarines. They carry instructions for three or four media at once, written with complete technical sincerity, and they leave it to the performer to discover which of those instructions the room they're actually standing in can honour. I'd call that the score being honest about how many places music has to travel through on the way to an ear.

The last one is the quietest. A delivery truck, all one color, a pale sage green, with a little orange ladder hooked on the back and a long pleated bellows along its side like an accordion that swallowed a radiator. It sits on a white plinth. It's the only vehicle in the set that has been put up on a pedestal, and the only one that plainly isn't going anywhere.

That's what happens to scores, eventually. They get archived, catalogued, photographed in good light, placed on a plinth in a library or a museum case or a PDF, and they keep every one of their wheels. The ladders still reach. The bellows still look as if they could breathe. Nothing in the object has changed, only its permission to move.

One last burst of the dialect, for the archive: the plinth effects a transposition of the vehicle from the register of potential kinesis into that of curated stasis, whereupon its mechanisms persist as pure signifiers of capacity, a mobility held in suspension, awaiting the reactivating gesture of a reader who may, at any moment, climb the little orange ladder and simply drive it off the pedestal.

I'd like to see that. I'd like to see the security guard's face.

No comments:

Post a Comment