Sunday, November 22, 2026

The Bounce, Six Years Later. Revisiting a 2020 post on careers, memes and the slow roll

 


The Bounce, Six Years Later

Revisiting a 2020 post on careers, memes and the slow roll

By Bil Smith

In 2020 I wrote here that a composer's reputation is built the slow way, score by score, performance by performance, over years, and that we had entered a moment of the bounce. A Google Alert fires when someone types your name. A tweet about a performance reaches thousands of people before the hall has emptied. I said the re-gestures, the retweet and the reblog, had come to carry more weight than the work being pointed at, and I ended by saying that composers still preferred the slow roll of music history to the bouncy meme, but that this too would soon be changing.

It changed. I got the direction wrong, though.

Everything in that post assumed a person on the other end of the bounce. Someone who saw my score, didn't read it, and passed it on anyway because the name and the look of the thing were worth passing on. I was annoyed by that person. Six years later I find I miss them.

Start with the platform I named. Twitter has been X since 2023, and new-music people have scattered to Bluesky, Threads, Mastodon, Instagram, a few Discord servers, and in some cases nowhere. There is no longer one room where a score can ricochet. There are a dozen half-empty rooms with the lights on.

The bigger change is who decides what travels. In 2020 a retweet was still a choice a person made, however lazily. Now the reach of a post is set mostly by a recommendation feed, TikTok's For You page and everything built to imitate it, which shows a thing to people who never chose to follow you because a model predicted they would linger on it. Followers matter less. Lingering matters more. A page of dense notation does well in that system when it makes someone pause their thumb for a second and a half, which is about the opposite of what the page asks of a player.

So the re-gesture I complained about has been automated. The pointing still happens, at a scale Boing Boing never managed, but there's often no one doing it. I used to resent the people who shared a score without reading it. At least they had seen it go by.

In the 2020 post I wrote that the citation, the act of moving information, had more cachet than the object it referred to. I still think so. What I didn't picture was a citation with no one behind it at all.

Type a composer's name into a search box now and the first thing you're likely to get is a machine-written paragraph above the links. Ask a chatbot about a score and it will tell you, calmly and in complete sentences, what the score is about and who it resembles. Some of that will be right. Some of it will be stitched together from program notes, a review, and a stranger's guess. The tone is identical either way, and very few people click through to check.

For a composer this means your work is now being described far more often than it is being read, and the description arrives already finished. In 2020 the bounce at least sent people toward the thing, even if they didn't look closely when they got there. A summary is built to be the place where they stop, and it takes the score's place.

I don't think a composer can opt out of this. You can try to make sure the material the machines read is accurate and your own, which is one reason I keep writing here at length instead of posting captions. I'd rather be summarized from something I actually said.

Then there's the object itself, the thing the bounce was supposed to be about.

People now write prompts for image generators asking for pages of viola notation dense enough to pass for late Ferneyhough, and the generators are very good at it. In seconds you get a sheet with beams, tuplets, microtonal arrows, stacked dynamics, all of it lit like a museum photograph. None of it can be played. The beams connect nothing in particular. The tuplets don't add up. It is a picture of difficulty, and as a picture it is often more striking than a real score, because it was optimized to be looked at.

That's the part that unsettles me. In 2020 the bounce traded on the look of a demanding score, and the demanding score still existed underneath, waiting for anyone patient enough to read it. Now the look can be produced on its own, with nothing underneath, and it will travel just as well. Probably better. The same is true of sound. Services like Suno will hand you a finished track from a sentence of description, and a feed can't tell the difference between that and something someone spent two years on. Neither can most listeners, scrolling.

Sneering at these tools gets nobody anywhere. They do make plain what the bounce was rewarding all along, which was the surface of the work, and the surface can now be made for free.

What can't be made for free is anything that only reveals itself to someone who stays with it.

One of my recent scores has three sums running up its right margin. Each one is wrong, and the way they are wrong matters to the piece. A summary will tell you there's a ledger in the margin. An image generator could produce a page with a ledger on it by lunchtime. Neither will tell you that 16 + 17 + 18 + 29 + 29 − 219 + 24 + 20 does not come to 90, because finding that out takes a pencil and a couple of minutes, and nobody downstream of the feed is spending those minutes. The only way to know is to do it yourself.

I've come to think that's the most useful thing a score can do right now: hold something back from the scroll. Put the meaning where it has to be worked out, by a player in a practice room or a reader with a pencil, and the bounce can carry the picture as far as it likes. The same goes for a performance. A feed can show you thirty seconds of one, but the forty minutes in the room with the player bending a pitch toward 23/16 and missing slightly and trying again doesn't compress.

In 2020 I said I couldn't name a composer who would choose the bouncy meme over the slow roll of history. I still can't. What I didn't see coming was how little the choice would be ours. The bounce goes on without us, faster each year, described by machines and illustrated by machines, and the slow roll is still there underneath it, for whoever is patient enough to dig it out. I can't tell yet whether that's a smaller audience or just a quieter one.

No comments:

Post a Comment